Jump to content

Geo GeoBook 1E Education Laptops - HORRIBLE!


Recommended Posts

Posted
Sounds like the old Dells

 

Commodore were famous for this in the last batches of the C64. They just used up all their old parts inventory

Posted (edited)
No luck! All i have is the DfE stating they do a flat fee repair.. for only £220.....

 

Sigh...

 

Yeah, I contacted Geo directly to see about getting parts and they said we don't offer that service and directed me to the DfE and noted £220 for 'repair'. Trying to source a compatible one from eBay but it looks like a bit of a gamble. I peeled back some tape on the screen that gives the number 'NT116WHM-N44' but that seems to show many variants. The key physical difference is they all seem to come with brackets at top/bottom or sides and the Geo doesn't have this. I don't believe that brackets on top/bottom would be an issue because they wouldn't get in the way so maybe going to take a punt at one from eBay for £39.00

Edited by bigal06
Posted

Who pays the £220? The school or the DfE?

 

Was wondering if the school could somehow get the £220 and get a Chromebook instead. At least the student could get on the internet...

Posted (edited)
Who pays the £220? The school or the DfE?

 

Was wondering if the school could somehow get the £220 and get a Chromebook instead. At least the student could get on the internet...

 

The school pays since ownership is signed over upon receipt of the devices. Ideally, the parents should pay but as the devices are given to families in need there is no way they could afford to fund the repairs.

Edited by bigal06
  • Thanks 1
Posted
I've gotta admit, reading this thread is very interesting, I never knew the UK DfE would buy laptops like these! I hope you people are doing alright enough with these
Posted
We have just been told we are getting 250 devices. Hoping to god we can choose anything but these things.

 

Quite.

 

In the twelve-odd years I've been using SCCM to image machines, I have never come across a more awkward device. Even those god-awful Linx Windows 8 tablets that were in vogue a few years ago weren't this bad.

  • Thanks 1
Posted
We have just been told we are getting 250 devices. Hoping to god we can choose anything but these things.

 

The ones they are currently sending out are Dell Dimension 3190s. We got another batch this week.

  • Thanks 1
Posted
Quite.

 

In the twelve-odd years I've been using SCCM to image machines, I have never come across a more awkward device. Even those god-awful Linx Windows 8 tablets that were in vogue a few years ago weren't this bad.

 

Get them set up using InTune using Autopilot. The DfE can provide you with the hardware hashes for them so in theory you don’t even need to touch them although we’re reinstalling Windows on all now!

Posted
Get them set up using InTune using Autopilot. The DfE can provide you with the hardware hashes for them so in theory you don’t even need to touch them although we’re reinstalling Windows on all now!

 

We considered that approach, but we imaged them for a few major reasons:

 

1) Alway On VPN device tunnels require Windows Enterprise or Education. Windows Pro for Education only supports user tunnels.

2) These devices are supposed to be going to disadvantaged students. We can't guarantee that they've got a decent internet connection, or that it hasn't been capped. Enrolling them into Intune then stuffing Office down the line might use their data

3) If we image them beforehand, we can guarantee a consistent software loadout and configuration.

Posted
The ones they are currently sending out are Dell Dimension 3190s. We got another batch this week.

 

Is that definitely a Dell Dimension? I thought they had stopped that line and they used to be Desktop models?

Posted
Has anyone had the Dynabook E10s? We are looking at splitting out allocation between ipads and these.

 

These ones?

 

Satellite Pro ET10-G-104

Celeron [email protected]

4GB RAM

32GB Disk

 

If so we've had one that had a dodgy keyboard connection but otherwise, much to my surprise from the spec, no other real problems yet.

  • Thanks 1
Posted
We considered that approach, but we imaged them for a few major reasons:

 

1) Alway On VPN device tunnels require Windows Enterprise or Education. Windows Pro for Education only supports user tunnels.

2) These devices are supposed to be going to disadvantaged students. We can't guarantee that they've got a decent internet connection, or that it hasn't been capped. Enrolling them into Intune then stuffing Office down the line might use their data

3) If we image them beforehand, we can guarantee a consistent software loadout and configuration.

 

Did you have success imaging with SCCM? I'm finding it an absolute nightmare. We're booting from a USB boot stick due to the lack of PXE boot, but the problem is most of them won't see a USB ethernet dongle at boot, you have to unplug and replug it. This means the task sequence fails because at every reboot step unless you are there to unplug/replug there is no network connection. I've got one or two so far that have been successful but most not. I've tried all the options in the BIOS relating to USB, disabled fast boot etc. Tried two different types of dongle. Injected the latest USB ethernet drivers into the WinPE boot image and the driver package deployed to the laptop during TS. We've used these same USBs on other laptops no problem. I'm going to have to build an offline task sequence on a USB HDD at this rate then just add to domain at the end? I've never ever come across such an awkward machine to image in my entire IT career spanning 20 years!

Posted
I imaged 17 of these last week, successfully PXE booted and imaged using startech usb 3 ethernet adaptors

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...