Jump to content

Laptop Suggestions for a pupil that will throw it around...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Now I know that you will say don't buy him one, we are not the authority is and have asked us to find one that will cope with being thrown around. The mention of militarty versions ha,

 

 

anyone have any suggestions?

Posted

More seriously, if one has to be provided then whoever is making the demand will have to suck it up and pay for a ruggedized machine (there are some "building site" type ones that may not be as ridiculously expensive as military spec machines).

 

I have also seen an Android tablet due out soon aimed at the construction industry.

Posted

We have RM minibooks for things like this. There were sold as "almost indestructable" but I haven't been allowed to test that claim.

 

From what I can see, it's based on an Asus Eee PC 701.

 

 

If you're looking for fullsized laptops, I can't help, sorry.

Posted
We have RM minibooks for things like this. There were sold as "almost indestructable" but I haven't been allowed to test that claim.

 

From what I can see, it's based on an Asus Eee PC 701.

 

 

If you're looking for fullsized laptops, I can't help, sorry.

 

Seconded.

Posted
Older Panasonic ToughBooks come in at reasonable prices. Bought one recently for our Grounds that was about £400. Still running on XP, but performance is just fine. To be honest, if you don't want to compromise on performance, then there is very little in the price range (that a normal school would consider justifiable), that will survive many attempts at willful destruction like this...
Posted
forget about a laptop, and get what we got for a special school when I worked in a previous job which was to get a hardened public console PC with a stainless keyboard and trackball. Still there, still working!
Posted
The Dell Latitude E6430 ATG is pretty tough, but you're looking at over a grand to buy one. Honestly not sure you'll find anything that isn't nailed down that will withstand a proper chuck though, plus the tougher it is the more it will hurt the person it's thrown at.
Posted (edited)
Now I know that you will say don't buy him one, we are not the authority is and have asked us to find one that will cope with being thrown around. The mention of militarty versions ha,

 

 

anyone have any suggestions?

 

In all seriousness though, If the authority is buying it, wouldn't it be better to let them pick one? Not trying to pass the buck, but no matter what you choose, it "can" be broken if the kid is being that violent with it, and I'd hate to be the person who suggested an indestructable item that got broke at those prices. :)

 

All these toughbooks are more designed from the outside in terms of protection. Sure dropping it, or spilling water etc on it may not destroy it. But a kid trying to break it... well yeah

 

Random youtube example:

 

 

As you can see, after only a few minutes (1:40~ if you want to skip video) of it being dropped on concrete, it's broke. Without any real effort, or even throwing it. It's sure a lot tougher than most laptops, but no way "safe" :)

 

But just my thoughts,

 

Steve

Edited by Steve21
  • Thanks 1
Posted
We have some Stone netbooks based around the Intel Classmate chassis. These things are completely rubberised and feel relatively sturdy. Stick an SSD in there and I think they'd cope OK with being thrown around.
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I'd take a look at the new Classmate 2S product - an updated version of the Fizzbook. New improved spec (Atom N2600 dual core, 2GB RAM and an all day battery) for what looks to be a lower price (quoted £359 for a Win 7 Pro unit)

 

It's got HDD inside but it's sw-protected, SSD only provides limited space for the money and if they protect it there seems to be no need to compromise space?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...