NFER (National Foundation of Educational Research) 2012 main survey

[A10]

Has anyone else come across the NFER PISA 2012 main survey system?

 

I've just been handed a USB drive and manual for this survey software that we will be supposedly undertaking in September. I don't think I've ever see such a suspicious set of instructions.

 

Basically we are supposed to run the software on this USB drive on each of the computers that will be used in the survey to confirm they meet the specifications and then return the drive to NFER. I don't know what everyone elses opinion is, but personally I dislike this kind of approach - let me tell you if we meet your specifications, and if I'm wrong then it's my fault. As part of this process you are also obliged to run their virus checker - their own notes state that the schools own antivirus will detect this as a virus ... 'This is normal and should be ignored'. Yeah right!

 

All the information that is gathered by this process is written back to the USB drive as a Truecrypt encrypted file. So there is no way we can see what information has been gathered. Again - why is this necessary?

 

On the testing day the students will need to "log in to the computer as a user with administrative rights" WTF??? Is there any school stupid enough to think this is a good idea? They do say that "if there are security concerns about having students logged into computers with full administrative rights..."

 

Am I alone in thinking that not one bit of this process is acceptable - or even professional?

 

Of course, as is usual with schools, we are under pressure to just do this regardless.

[wadtech]

Actually still battling this... Even with a special security group allowing local admin rights, students still can't run it.

 

It's come at the worst time with a huge summer project and the resulting battering we've had at the beginning of term.

 

Everything about it is suspect, especially running their antivirus on our PCs.

 

The manual is quick to stress that it is a Windows issue for needing administrative rights, but I wonder what exactly the exam client needs to do that requires these sort of rights.

[greenj2]

We have also been asked to get ready for this survey, with a condensed set of instructions and a USB key. We too have concerns. What software ? website ? are the students going to have to access to complete the survey ? and why do students need admin rights ?, why does it tell us not to update the anti-virus software on the USB drive ? We are going to make sure our anti-virus software is up to date and run a scan on their memory stick !

 

Does anyone have any answers?

[wadtech]

We have also been asked to get ready for this survey, with a condensed set of instructions and a USB key. We too have concerns. What software ? website ? are the students going to have to access to complete the survey ? and why do students need admin rights ?, why does it tell us not to update the anti-virus software on the USB drive ? We are going to make sure our anti-virus software is up to date and run a scan on their memory stick !

 

Does anyone have any answers?

 

No idea, but here's how I managed to get it working in our environment (warning- gore)

 

Security group containing the PCs to be used for testing

GPO filtered by that group that adds a local administrator account

Local account to be used only in test situation (we will log in to it beforehand) and PCs to probably be rebuilt afterwards.

 

It's ridiculous, just to run a full-screened portable Firefox with some rubbishy quiz software built in (check the USB stick... Apache server?!)

 

Only upside is that the local administrator won't get proxy settings so no anonymous internet access.

 

Nobody knows which room has been booked for this exam (we have our date now) so I didn't even test it on the right machines. What is the point?

[jonspurs]

Hello,

Just curious on how everyone is getting / got on?

We've run the diagnostic crap, but we logged in as a student, right-clicked the PISAmenu.exe and ran as administrator. I assume the test will be in a similar manner, eg PISAtest.exe?

Cheers,

Jon

[wadtech]

Hello,

Just curious on how everyone is getting / got on?

We've run the diagnostic crap, but we logged in as a student, right-clicked the PISAmenu.exe and ran as administrator. I assume the test will be in a similar manner, eg PISAtest.exe?

Cheers,

Jon

 

We ran ours the other day, it works in exactly the same way, PISAmenu.exe. Click the test (or exam, or something) button and it runs the same old basic check before opening the exam proper (the diagnostics options are also available)

 

It runs a full-screen portable firefox with a javascript-based test. You may be prompted to allow apache through the firewall but I don't think it actually dials out anywhere.

 

Our invigilators weren't very well versed in running it but they did have documentation with them, they'll have a master password that you have to enter to show the student ID/password screen which is where it should be ready for the students.

 

All in all went pretty smoothly, just weird how it's so 'do this,' without any proper explanation.

[jonspurs]

Wadtech thanks alot for your reply, you've made it clear, which the PISA crap didn't. We're going to do the 'Run as administrator' option, hopefully will be as smooth as your method.

Next time any software / test that comes along with 'admin rights' we're just going to decline.

 

Let you know how we get on.

Jon

[wadtech]

Wadtech thanks alot for your reply, you've made it clear, which the PISA crap didn't. We're going to do the 'Run as administrator' option, hopefully will be as smooth as your method.

Next time any software / test that comes along with 'admin rights' we're just going to decline.

 

Let you know how we get on.

Jon

 

No problem.

 

Our approach was a bit belt-and-braces but thankfully the teacher who had to arrange the exam and the invigilators were all happy to pitch in and click a few buttons/type a few passwords.

 

As an interesting aside: Our invigilator mentioned that another school didn't have to do the computer part since they didn't pass diagnostics (hmmm!).

[jonspurs]

Yo,

Just to say it all went fine on our end...run as administrator.

Next time i reckon diagnostics 'won't work'... ;-)

[Ex-MGSTech]

We said no thanks and were told by the DFE in no uncertian terms we WOULD do the survey!

Agree if written correctly NON of it requires admin rights Grrrr

[howartp]

Fast forward 6 years to June 2018 and I've had the same pile of c**p land on my desk.

 

They've finally emailed me to see why I haven't sent back the diagnostics, so I've let them know what I think of the whole setup.

 

Waiting to see what becomes of it!

 

Peter