Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I presume what3words is very careful about making "interesting" combinations?

 

I had a password generator the other day spit out "BentGirl17!" or something similar, and the even shakier "BlackFailure1_?" which I felt was one to avoid....

Posted
You would hope that they have thought about the combinations and when they put it together you can bet that they had a whole list of banned words.
Posted
TBH it would not take much to get all the combinations using powershell and the API. Thats why i say you need to add your own randomisation to the output from what 3 words.
Posted
My interest was sparked so i did a little digging in to what 3 words and by all accounts there are ~170,000 words in the Oxford English Dictionary by the time they had removed the words that could not be used they where left with ~40,000 words to use for the required 57 trillion unique 3 word combinations! So even if i scraped all of the combinations using a script and we added no other randomisation the task of finding an account and matching it to a what 3 word generated combination is no small task in its self... But mixing it up with other randomisations stops an attack based solely on those 57 trillion combinations.
  • Thanks 1
Posted
This is a neat idea. But yes, always worth taking the time to pass any lists of generated passwords through a human blandification filter before dishing them out.
Posted

How long is it going to take the entire Edugeek community to click on the 57 trillion 3m3 tiles to find and list the funny combinations? :D

 

If you get the long/ lats we can exclude those in the script...

  • Thanks 2
Posted

I'd be weary about adding a third party service as a requirement of the new account process. It can't be helped in some cases, you will probably need to set up Cloud accounts as part of the process but it would be a bit annoying if the process failed because the what 3 words API was down for some reason.

 

Also, I don't like how the company make it free to convert a location to three words but charge for reversing the process but that's not important if you are just using it as a random word generator.

  • Thanks 1
Posted
I'd be weary about adding a third party service as a requirement of the new account process. It can't be helped in some cases, you will probably need to set up Cloud accounts as part of the process but it would be a bit annoying if the process failed because the what 3 words API was down for some reason.

 

Also, I don't like how the company make it free to convert a location to three words but charge for reversing the process but that's not important if you are just using it as a random word generator.

I can see how that could be an issue for large organisations, although I suspect they price it so that the operational efficiency savings outweigh the costs.

 

For personal use I have the app on my phone to find the three word address and then share it either to a navigation app or my car to get standard gps coordinates and directions which doesn't cost me anything.

Posted
@David44 that is a fair point and can be handled in code mind, if its a cloud service then it should all be cloud and if on prem it should be on prem only. But that limits our ability to find natty solutions in some cases.
Posted
And on that i could code a solution that could cache a few calls and make it so the random long lat dont use those for x amount of time.
Posted
I wonder if it's worth maintaining a blocklist of words to check generated passwords against, to avoid culturally loaded or common password words. ///administrator.password.monkey is a valid w3w address, and might be okay from a password strength point of view, but you'd probably feel better skipping it, given the choice.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...