danielson81 Posted May 27, 2014 Posted May 27, 2014 Hi, I've received three quotes for 32 new PCs, the third one looks tempting, but is the first one worth paying extra for? I get the impression it wont make a lot of difference with a SSD drive and 8GB RAM already there. 1) Intel Core i5 4460 Processor 8GB DDR3 1600Mhz Memory 128Gb SSD DVD-RW Keyboard & Mouse Windows 8.1 Pro 5yr On Site Warranty 18.5" VGA LED Monitor - £430+VAT - Supplier builds own PCs. - x 32 = £13,760 2) Intel Core i5-4440 Quad Core 3.1Ghz 6MB LGA1150 Processor 8GB RAM DVD-RW Keyboard & Mouse 120GB SSD Windows 8.1 Pro 64Bit 5 Year On Site WARRANTY 18.5" VGA LED Monitor - £429+VAT - Supplier resells PCs (HP/Lenovo/Zoostorm/Dell etc) - x 32 = £13,728 3) Intel Core i5 Processor i5-3340 3.10GHz, Quad Core with 6MB Cache 8GB RAM DVD-RW Keyboard & Mouse 120GB SSD Windows 8.1 Pro 64Bit 5 Year On Site WARRANTY 19.5" VGA LED Monitor - £404+VAT - Supplier builds own PCs. - x 32 = £12,928
hawc Posted May 27, 2014 Posted May 27, 2014 I'd say 3 as it was cheapest, although it has slightly smaller SSD, it also has a bigger screen for the PC.
localzuk Posted May 27, 2014 Posted May 27, 2014 The difference in CPU performance is minimal. The 3340 also runs at a lower voltage, so potentially you will also save money in terms of running costs over their lives (its only 7W difference, but when you multiply that out over the number of machines and their lives, and it becomes a few hundred quid saving). The only differences I can tell are: The 3340 doesn't have FMA3 and AVX2 instruction support, which realistically in a school are unlikely to make much difference to the lives of the machines. The 4470 is about 10% faster The 3340 is about 8% more power efficient. On the other components - you'll not notice the "8GB" difference on SSD - once you've dealt with the 1000bit to 1024bit conversion that manufacturer's use, and formatted it down, you'll only notice a couple of GB difference. The monitor is your biggest difference - that exta 1" can be very useful to many users. So, all that said, I'd go for the cheapest one of those 3. Its by far the best deal.
Boredguy Posted May 27, 2014 Posted May 27, 2014 Quote 3 is an IvyBridge i5 compared to the other two being for Haswell i5's, however the processing power is comparable so on my best value system, quote 3 would be looking as my preferred option as it gets you a saving of over £700 and a larger monitor. I doubt the older processer would be an issue since the main difference on the Intel website is the graphics chip and I think the 2500 driver would still be perfectly acceptable over the 4600 for our normal workstation use.
Arthur Posted May 28, 2014 Posted May 28, 2014 (edited) If the PCs are going to be used by students, I would ditch the DVD writers to avoid damage and save a few quid on each computer. Edit. I would also try to get monitors with a digital connection (DVI, HDMI or DisplayPort). The image be sharper and you won't have to keep pressing the auto-adjust button when the screen goes wonky. Edited May 28, 2014 by Arthur
Hefferzzzz Posted May 28, 2014 Posted May 28, 2014 Whilst the cheapest price is tempting, whats the support like? When its this close I tend to ignore the cost and go with who I think will mess things up the least and put it right quickly when it does go wrong which invariably it will - DOA etc.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now