Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi

 

I have tried to use tagging on a workstation but it still doesn't work on any other vlans apart from the default one.

 

Has anyone else had any problems with using vlan tagging on workstations?

 

Switch had the other VLAN tagged and I've added the VLAN number into the driver properties in Windows 7. Tried a Realtek card and a intel desktop CT card with no luck.

Posted

default vlan is untagged and additional vlan is tagged

 

the PCs were originally setup for use by the community, so they used a different filtering schema than the rest of the school (it was the old ADMIN vlan supplied by CLEO). We now wish to use them for school use as well.

 

So I thought it would be an easy method of setting up dual boot (community and school) so that each instance of windows was setup differently and that the school instance used the default vlan whilst the community instance used the ADMIN / additional vlan.

 

the switch itself is a HP Procurve 2626 and I have tried a HP Procurve 2610-48 with the same result - it will not accept being put on the additional vlan :(

 

when I create a vlan in either the Intel or Realtek software, it creates an additional NIC. The original NIC properties is empty whereas the additional NIC has all the usual properties, and its in there I set the IP address needed.

 

I have even tried setting the additional vlan as the default, but when I try and set the vlan to the school network it doesnt pick up DHCP.

 

 

Any other ideas you can think of to achieve the required setup? we dont want the community to have access to our school network.

 

Thanks

Posted

I could be mistaken (and hopefully some more knowledgeable guys would correct me if so) but I would imagine a switch wouldn't know how to handle that sort of setup. As far as the switch is concerned, there's only one PC with one NIC and therefore one MAC address. By default, and certainly the case on a 2626, the switch will not do dynamic vlans therefore it'll probably get mightily confused with that sort of going on - host tables and the likes. Although it's quite possible for most filtering systems to do so by subnet/vlan, it would be easier certainly to do filtering by user/AD group which shouldn't matter what windows is installed on the system.

I certainly wouldn't trust tagging to a workstation unless you needed to, much less so when there's multiple OS's on the same box.

Posted

The filtering that I wanted to use was the filtering at the ISP, so separate from AD. I thought vlan tagging was simple to use and secure.

 

I might have have to implement a separate proxy server for the account for the community. Something I didn't want to do :(

Posted
More than likely. May be worth speaking to someone at the ISP (is it via your local authority?) and see if they have any ideas. Usually there would be something locally which would handle AD integration or vlan traffic.
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

Its its one PC and one NIC then you need to make sure that the NIC is capable of support vlans, you'll need to tag all the vlans that you want to use on the switch and then at the PC end enable vlan tagging. Intel cards have pro set software that allows you to do this, not sure about others.

 

Ash.

Posted

Thanks. Both the on-board NIC and I have also tried a Intel Gigabit CT Desktop Adapter with no success. The additional VLANs were tagged on the switch but it didn't seem to work :(

 

Its its one PC and one NIC then you need to make sure that the NIC is capable of support vlans, you'll need to tag all the vlans that you want to use on the switch and then at the PC end enable vlan tagging. Intel cards have pro set software that allows you to do this, not sure about others.

 

Ash.

Posted
One thing you could try would be 802.11x to put the machine in a van then setting a different Mac address in the driver of the second boot partition so the switch assigns it to the nessisary van.
Posted
You mean when changing the VLAN on the NIC, give it another MAC Address? Never tried that, but how would I know the MAC Address I give it is unique?
Posted
You mean when changing the VLAN on the NIC, give it another MAC Address? Never tried that, but how would I know the MAC Address I give it is unique?

 

You would not change the van on the card, the switch would assign that port to a different undated vlan when it detected it, there are stacks of Mac addresses and they only need to be unique on your local unrouted network, your chances of hitting another one are remote but you can check against a list exported from your dhcp server to make sure.

Posted
Just to point out the VLAN offers NO security! VLAN hopping is trivial.

 

When compared with two os'es on the one physically accessible machines I think that is probably the least of the security issues. Also while it may be trivial for some it has yet to reach the pop culture status of proxies to bypass filtering just yet.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...