timbo343 Posted February 17, 2025 Posted February 17, 2025 For those that are using the Bromcom Classes > Google Classroom sync. We've been going through our Google accounts to see which accounts are huge and we came across our Bromcom > Google Sync account which is nearly 900Gb in size. Taking a look into the account the Google Drive part of the account looks as if it has all class resources in. Is this normal? I thought it was there as a connector / service account not as an account that will be used to store / access all the documents of each of the classes. This means we are potentially backing up all our Google Classroom via this one account, and then backing up the student's and teacher's Google Classroom too. To me this doesn't make sense. Is this because the Bromcom > Google classroom service account is part of all the classrooms so it automatically sees everything and then it gets linked to everything? Is there a way to stop this from happening or is this just how it is?
David44 Posted February 17, 2025 Posted February 17, 2025 I believe the Google Classroom resources are stored in the Google Drive of whichever account owns the class. For us, this is the 'Main Teacher' from our MIS. For you, it may be that the Bromcom user is the owner of all the classes. Do they appear as a teacher when you look at the Teachers tab of a Google Classroom? The data shouldn't be duplicated though, each document will be owned by one user at a time, when a student hands-in their work it will go in to the owner's drive.
timbo343 Posted February 17, 2025 Author Posted February 17, 2025 I believe the Google Classroom resources are stored in the Google Drive of whichever account owns the class. For us, this is the 'Main Teacher' from our MIS. For you, it may be that the Bromcom user is the owner of all the classes. Do they appear as a teacher when you look at the Teachers tab of a Google Classroom? The data shouldn't be duplicated though, each document will be owned by one user at a time, when a student hands-in their work it will go in to the owner's drive. The account we use to sync classes from Bromcom to Google Classroom is a member of each class - yup. I thought this is how it has to work for the teachers and students to be automatically added to each Google Classroom. I wonder if the account we are using is actually the class owner of all the classes? Goes to look! > Yep the account we are using is actually the owner of all the classes form Bromcom. One way of looking at this is a good thing because we know that this is where all the classes and data lives so in a way we are backing up Classroom. Another way of looking at this is, should it really be set up like this? One of the positives is that we as IT Support can see troubleshoot the classes if there is ever an issue. Just looking over Bromcom and can i heck find the location of where this account for syncing Bromcom classes to Google Classroom. I can see under Config > Setup > Google Integration that there is an initial connection email address but this is different to the one that is for Classroom and the Bromcom to Google Classroom sync account is not listed in any of the groups / classes in Bromcom.
Primus Posted February 17, 2025 Posted February 17, 2025 I'm not sure you'd be able to do it differently - the creator of the class is always the owner and whilst you could transfer ownership to the teacher I'm not sure if you could then synchronise people into the class if the service account didn't own it.
David44 Posted February 17, 2025 Posted February 17, 2025 Our service account has the 'Manage Classes' role in Google Admin. It isn't the owner and doesn't appear as a teacher of any classes. It can add staff and students to classes and create classes with other accounts as the owner. We have our own in-house syncing process though and we don't use Bromcom so it may be true to say you can't do it differently when using Bromcom but it's not a Google limitation.
Primus Posted February 17, 2025 Posted February 17, 2025 Our service account has the 'Manage Classes' role in Google Admin. It isn't the owner and doesn't appear as a teacher of any classes. It can add staff and students to classes and create classes with other accounts as the owner. We have our own in-house syncing process though and we don't use Bromcom so it may be true to say you can't do it differently when using Bromcom but it's not a Google limitation. Interesting, I meant to mention we use Salamander for ours. I wonder if the API has developed over time - when did you develop your solution? 1
David44 Posted February 18, 2025 Posted February 18, 2025 We probably started looking at it around 2019 and it is constantly under development. We have always created Classrooms with owners other than the service account though.
Primus Posted February 18, 2025 Posted February 18, 2025 We probably started looking at it around 2019 and it is constantly under development. We have always created Classrooms with owners other than the service account though. Interesting, we find it useful for one account to own each year group's classes - makes it easy to jump in and have a look at them and for SLT to look at classes before the visit a class feature existed.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now