Koldov Posted January 18, 2019 Posted January 18, 2019 I am just going to leave this here for the weekend.... I know sometimes that it may seem funny to put 'Let me Google that for you'... But this is an open forum with many, many varying levels of experience. Personally I love EDUGEEK, so don't get me wrong, it has helped me more times than it has left me hanging. But I usually come to ask for help if it is either one of two scenarios: A) I have Googled the heck out of it and either can't find the answer or don't understand it. or B) It is really important I get this fixed NOW and I can't afford to spend all day on Google. So I wonder why I see so many threads on here follow this theme? Q: I am having (problem description) trouble with XYZ v1.0. Could somebody help? First response... A1: Why are you still using XYZ v1.0, everybody should now be using XYZ v2.0. This could be read a little bit like 'Hey, I am fantastic and you are not, my team with our unlimited budget needed to rebuild our entire network and all the machines connected to it to install V2.0, you should have done it years ago etc.' Not everyone has the time, budget, manpower, resources or even the need to upgrade to all new and shiny every time the next version of something comes out. Let alone the skill/experience to do it (and then break everything in the process requiring more time/effort spent troubleshooting/fixing). Second response... A2: Here is a handy link to 30 pages of technical specification for XYZ v1.0 Not actually very helpful, am I right? Or not? It's a bit like someone saying they are having trouble learning to read and when they ask for help, you give them War and Peace... Please discuss...
3s-gtech Posted January 18, 2019 Posted January 18, 2019 From me, there are usually two types of responses to threads. There’s the quick - probably tapped out on a phone, to give some general help or pointers when I don’t have the time or the equipment available to do a comprehensive search for an answer (this is most of mu posts). The there’s the detailed - I will research, draw upon my own experience, provide some links or screenshots. So often when you get a response it’ll depend on what others are doing at the time, and whether they have the time to sit down and work through your issue. The ‘you should be on v2.0’ debate is a tough one. Many of us have become exasperated by people asking how to get something working in Server 2003, or Exchange 2007, or even XP, well after they’ve been EOL’d. It’s often tough to mask the surprise that $system is still in use; even tougher to not tell that user to upgrade ASAP. We do try to help as much as we can, and the combined knowledge on Edugeek makes many other sites redundant (though Spiceworks is also very useful). During a busy day it’s often tough to put together a detailed response, and you can see that from people’s posts. You can always ignore the less useful posts though! 1
mikeprice Posted January 18, 2019 Posted January 18, 2019 One of the best things about this site is that people on here tend to assume that you are a reasonable person (stop sniggering at the back) and have tried what you can. In some cases the poster may be a solo IT Tech being paid naff all to keep the whole network of a secondary school running in spite of having had no decent investment since dinosaurs were wandering past the window hence they are overworked and need some help and support so an answer of RTFM is not useful! in my opinion RTFM is not useful anyway without some sort of pointer to page number and/or online examples In used to be on a forum about the VMS operating system that often used to reply with RTFM - but the regulars would normally come back with volume/page number or something to help - but they did expect you to have read the manual before posting But in those days we had several cabinets full of manuals in the office (or on my desk at times!!) - those were the days - fully documented operating systems!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now