It's funny, after reading all these responses, that it's still difficult to get the definitive answer! Big mix of emotional responses and practical issues. It's undoubtedly a band wagon, but that alone does seem to motivate teachers and children. The over-hype is a small price to pay for more confidence and enthusiasm for ICT.
We've just massaged the first 20 units of LearnPads into a school and they do look like a viable alternative to the iPads. (We don't sell them, so there's no hidden agenda here!) Some pros and some cons - here are a few that spring to mind
Pros
- Centrally managed solution
- Android based, so a much more open approach than Apple.
- Cost
- Built in Educational Apps
- Group/User based experience. You log on and get a tailored environment. Apple will apparently never support this.
- It supports Flash
- Alternatives to native apps. (Keyboard, browser, email client etc., can all be changed.)
- Easy data exchange using USB flash drives.
Cons
- Educational apps on marketplace are not as extensive as Apple community.
- No rear facing camera - BIG disappointment that they need to address. Multimedia is one of the key reasons the schools are looking at iPads.
- All a bit Beta at the moment, but very promising!