Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

public publishing is free afaik. It's when you want to restrict it that you have to pay.

@GREED your market share calculations screw up the second you try to do any multi-year comparisons :(

Posted
public publishing is free afaik. It's when you want to restrict it that you have to pay.

@GREED your market share calculations screw up the second you try to do any multi-year comparisons :(

 

Which tab are you on (1-7 on the bottom) - which page? DM me if want to take offline so can understand and fix if needed.

Posted

sorry - busy day today - I hadn't even looked past tab 1 :(

 

so anyway, tab 1 - only filter selected is "2018" - SIMS market share is 78.91% which is obscene but believable.

 

Let's then pick 2017 as well - the number of schools looks sensible- 17101 in 2018 and 17632 in 2017 - but the percentages aren't doing anything clever - so we've got 38.91 for 2018 and 40.12 for 2017 - this is wrong.

 

Even more fun is that if we pick just one year and one MIS then that MIS get's 100% of marketshare. If we pick a second MIS they just split the 100% between them.

 

At each point the numbers look fine, it's just that your percentage calculations aren't being at all clever.

 

While writing this I had a play with tab 2 and that seems to be a lot more sensible - the percentages look to my untrained eye as if they are behaving when combining filters.

  • Thanks 1
Posted

I'll take a look one evening this week, but the filtering is done based on the raw stats available - so those values are correct because 17000 odd of 22,000 school is around the 80% mark, but 17,000 of 44,000 is around 40%. It is not correct based on what is trying to be displayed, but it is right based on the values and the filtering taking place. The tables are not perfect I know that but the best way to display the key headlines we all want to see for 1 year - multi-year not so much, that is what the chart is for, or look on tab 6 for the year by year numbers. The tables are 'live filtering' they are not hiding and showing rows.

 

Of course, appreciate the feedback and will look into what I can improve.

Posted
Thanks for creating this Graham, it makes interesting reading. FYI you can set slicers to be single select if you wanted to limit it to one year at a time.
Posted
Thanks for creating this Graham, it makes interesting reading. FYI you can set slicers to be single select if you wanted to limit it to one year at a time.
I'm reconsidering it I wanted to leave as flexible as possible but if it is not making sense then will look at it again. Once again thanks for the feedback all, I want it to be right and useful!
Posted
just out of interest, where is source information from? is it available as a csv somewhere?
It comes from many csvs supplied by the DfE via FoI. I then pump those into SQL using SSIS, much easier to work with then.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...