Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi All,

 

OK, so I'm getting myself in a right mucking fuddle here with permissions and I know they are not something to take lightly.

 

As I'm on a little security mission at the moment I decided to look at permissions, as I remember someone saying that they only give users read access to the root of the drive.

 

So I check mine...

 

Starting at the root (drive letter in explorer) I pick up the properties and check 'Sharing' - Not Shared. So far so good. On 'Security' there is an entry for 'Users' - Read & Execute, List Folder Contents, Read...

 

Further in on 'Advanced' it has 'Authenticated Users' - Modify, Users (DOMAIN\Users - Read & Execute).

 

But there is an entry for the 'Everyone' group that has 'Special permissions' - These are Read & Execute (This folder only).

 

I'm tempted to just remove them, but what are the implications?

 

Next, out of interest I check the root of the C:\ on the server...

 

Not shared, OK. Security also has the 'DOMAIN\Users' group in - Read & Execute, List Folder Contents, Read and Special Permissions!!!

 

On the advanced tab these permissions allow the 'User' group to:

 

Read & Execute

Create Folder / Append data

Create Files / Write Data

 

I thought I would check out who was in the 'User' group.

 

In AD I find 'Users' (Ordinary Users) in the Builtin OU and check the properties to see that the members are a strange bunch of system accounts (Authenticated Users, INTERACTIVE, SQL agent) but one old staff member is there!

 

In the Members list there is 'Domain Users' group. Who is a member of that group....? Everyone..!

 

Is this safe, because they are not 'shared'?

 

It looks like I'm going to go round in circles and lose my mind trying to fathom out who should have what permissions and as they are all very old from a system I inherited, I'm concerned about removing permissions obviously.

 

I could get lost in Google forever trying to work it out and probably end up locking half the school out and stopping the backups running, so I wondered if anyone might share their wisdom on the best practises for permissions?

 

I know it is all individual, but looking at the server, if I remove the 'User' permission here, am I removing the option for the system to do some operations it needs to (for backups or the like)?

 

Users.jpg

 

So in effect it should look like:

 

DATADRIVE1 (E:) - (Not Shared) (Security Permissions - SYSTEM, DOMAIN\Administrators) - This is the root right?

 

SHARED FOLDER 1 (ADMIN) - (SHARED -> Everyone) - (Security Permissions -> SYSTEM, DOMAIN\Administrators, Admin Staff)

SHARED FOLDER 2 (TEACHER DATA) - (SHARED -> Everyone) - (Security Permissions -> SYSTEM, DOMAIN\Administrators, Teacher Group)

SHARED FOLDER 3 (PUPIL DATA) - (SHARED -> Everyone) - (Security Permissions -> SYSTEM, DOMAIN\Administrators, Teacher Group, Pupil Group)

 

If shared folder have explicit permissions, do they need permissions for generic groups like 'users', 'authenticated users', 'domain users' and such? Is not more secure to have each folder share to only have permissions for named users, or security groups?

 

I know it's a big ask, but thanks in advance!

 

Kol.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...