Interesting thread, we're in the same sitatuion our CC3 network is due for replacement, we are looking at CC4 and a plain setup from our LEA.
I'm at two schools, one already has the LEA Plain network - for a year now - and as people have said it has some advantages over RM, and CC3 has advantages over the plain one.
Just to say it again, the decision needs to be taken which is best for the school. The CC3network I'm barely on site for 15hours a week, so if we go to a vanilla setup I could be spending the best part of that keeping the network in check and have less time for everything else I need to do such as MLE training, supporting lessons as needed etc.
It also means that if I am away for whatever reason, another member of staff can take hold of the network and do basic implementation of various tasks thanks to the management console. They wouldn't have a clue how to do it on a vanilla setup.
I find at the end of the day the decision will need to be taken by the Head & ICT Co-Ordinator, I can give pros/cons of both systems, but they need to decide what is best for the school and the daily teaching and use of ICT rather than what is best for me.
Even on the vanilla setup, a year in, we are still tweaking GPOs and settings to stop the kids finding loopholes in the system - admittedly the children are younger on the CC3 site - but we've had less security issues in the 4 years of CC3 than in a year on the vanilla setup. Although not saying thats a selling point for RM, part of it is down to the setup and configuration of the server initally!
Also it might come down to support, our LEA has a bad reputation for support, they only have something like 8 support technicians and it can take hours, sometimes days for someone to come to the site. Ours are very good at the "oh you have a go, and if it doesn't work we'll send someone out" attitude. They also supply Dell computers, the other issue is that Dell's technical support - although improving - can be an issue too. Seems to depend who you get and what level of service support you have with Dell.
I find the issue for switching also comes down to software, at the CC3 site they use a fair bit of RM software, if they want to continue using this and buy licences for the software it gets expensive and brings up the cost of the vanilla network.
I've calculated that RM would cost around £12,000 for our site including support and licences. The vanilla setup on hardware is just £8000, but by the time you've added the LEA support (£1000) plus potential software licencing for some RM software (£2000 or so) we are pretty much near the same price point!