Wired Networks Thread, Am I mad? School broadband cost versus home in Technical; Hi, I'm new here so apologies if this question has been answered, but I'm just blown away by this...
1st February 2012, 08:09 PM #1
- Rep Power
Am I mad? School broadband cost versus home
Hi, I'm new here so apologies if this question has been answered, but I'm just blown away by this...
My local school spends £8.5k per year on broadband, the equivalent of around £700 per month. For 10MB ADSL.
At home, 1 mile away, I get 100MB cable broadband for around £35 a month.
Can someone help me understand?! I have one computer at home, getting 10x the speed of my school, for 5% of the cost?!!
Something is wrong about this.
IDG Tech News
1st February 2012, 08:18 PM #2
The school really has just 10mb adsl and not a 10mb symetric connection?
It probably also connects to a regional broadband consortium and meets e-safety requirements.
1st February 2012, 08:27 PM #3
Exactly what is said above. the 10mb is also probably 10mb each way (plus its going to be 10mb) your 100mb would fluctuate depending how many others are online. Then there is filtering of both web traffic and also email etc.
Originally Posted by misources
We have just ordered a 100mb leased line for 12.5k
1st February 2012, 08:29 PM #4
8.5k p/a for a 10Mb/s line is an absolute rip-off. Our Local Authority sells this to unsuspecting primary school head teachers.
You should be able to get a 10Mb/s connection for round 4k with an EFM line.
Difficult to compare to home connections because with a dedicated line you get a 1:1 contention (unless, as in the case of our LA they contend it with other schools!) The other bits that you don't get with home connections are synchronised line, service level agreement (money back if they screw up) and a backup line.
1st February 2012, 08:30 PM #5
You'll probably find that you get a whole heap of other services thrown in. For our several £Ks a year we get synchronous broadband via a managed proxy server, filtering, email, web hosting, technical support and loads of extra goodies. I would suspect that providing secure internet access that meets all requiremets in terms of security and safety is going to cost you a bit more than £35 a month.
1st February 2012, 09:15 PM #6
- Rep Power
Right, but to answer a few responses from above, at home I get 100MB down, and 10MB up...AND during the hours of 9am to 3pm when a school uses the cable from the residential road it's in, hardly anyone at all is sharing the connection. And as £35 per month is 5% the cost, I could take 3 lines if I liked?!
Originally Posted by laserblazer
And all this 'you get extra stuff' business...I just can't get over it...a 'managed' proxy server?! you mean some software a team of 2/3 kids could code in a weekend sitting on web server somewhere? Filtering? Ditto. E-mail?!!!!!!!! E-mail has been free FOREVER! Google Apps for Education is a classic example. Hosting?!!!! I've got an all-I-can-eat reseller hosting account that costs me £40 per month. Technical support? When has a broadband provider ever given technical support?
I'm sorry, I just can't get over what an unbelievable heist is going on here. Schools like mine are being ripped off by a huge factor.
Emperor. Clothes. New.
2 Thanks to misources:
nathan3388 (11th June 2012), SimpleSi (10th June 2012)
1st February 2012, 09:24 PM #7
Without being funny it doesn't work like that. Yes there are solutions out there that are free (I use a lot of them myself being a linux person). But having a fully managed service costs. Saying Email has been free forever isn't true - for a properly managed service anyway (in relative terms google apps/lice@edu are fairly new).
Originally Posted by misources
When it doesn't work (although it tends to be rubbish if you are calling from home)
When has a broadband provider ever given technical support?
1st February 2012, 09:30 PM #8
- Rep Power
I'm sorry, but I have to push back on the e-mail one - a 'managed service' from a uk company is one that runs something like Exchange servers in a hugely costly way, and is only 'managed' because it's based on server technology designed for corporations in a client/server model. The exchange servers will fall over, or even the linux mail solution will go down because the hosting provider will have an outage. Gmail, or Hotmail, it makes no difference, is centrally run in some of the world's most efficient data centres run by some of the wealthiest companies on the planet who have a brand to maintain far more important than the company providing a 'managed' service. If you get Linux, you surely get this concept?!
Originally Posted by glennda
1st February 2012, 09:38 PM #9
There are plenty of posts on EG about the differences between home and school internet connections, and it seems to be an annually asked question. Apart from the contention issues, guaranteed speed, service levels and the legal/safety/privacy issues of school connections you really cannot compare the two due to reasons other people have already stated.
1st February 2012, 09:39 PM #10
I don't quite get what you're ranting about?
1st February 2012, 09:43 PM #11
- Rep Power
Quite simply the 20x delta between the cost of a very high quality service I recieve at home (£35 per month versus £700), to the one my school gets with 10% of the download speed (10MB at school, versus my 100MB), and the same upload speed (10MB each).
Originally Posted by plexer
1st February 2012, 09:44 PM #12
School internet connections are generally not like home connections. Here are a few considerations (it is by no means a complete list)
1. Contention - a home connection will typically be on a 1:50 contention, whereas a fibre line will be much lower than that (if it is a direct connection to an RBC, it'll likely be closer to 1:1).
2. Proxy - this is not something to be sniffed at. Proper filtering that complies with all the requirements that schools have is not cheap. If you go out and buy an off the shelf box to do it, you're looking at several thousand pounds a year just for filtering.
3. Email - Sure, there are free email services, but these are very recent and new. Many schools feel that services such as Google Apps don't provide the service that they require in terms of filtering, management and control. If a school doesn't want to go 'cloud', then an email service for a school is a costly endeavour. Remember - accountability is needed in a school, and free services sometimes cannot provide that.
4. Routing - your home router might be able to handle that 100Mbit connection for the handful of devices connected to it, but try getting 100, 200 etc... devices to connect. The thing will basically curl up and die. So, instead, a corporate style router is needed and again, these cost a significant amount of money.
5. Hosting - All you can eat hosts are notoriously bad. Overselling is rife in that category. This isn't a particularly expensive item to add to the bill when done right, but it is something that many schools like thrown in, as it is something less to think about.
6. Technical support - this is incredibly important. An internet connection in a school is kind of like electricity or water now. Down time is detrimental to lessons, and as such being able to get through to and able to talk to a tech support person when you need to is an absolute must.
7. SLAs - mixed with 6, because of the requirements of a modern school on their internet connection, downtime can be seriously disruptive to the normal running of a school. So, business and education offerings often now have an SLA which guarantees a certain level of uptime and service. In order to be able to provide those service levels, the providers have to charge more so that they can invest in better redundancy and better systems.
8. Location - if the school is rural, getting a fibre connection to them is not cheap, as it generally has to be run a longer distance, this will also have meant an expensive install cost which the ISP will want to recoup if the school didn't pay it outright.
9. Extras - If the connection is via an RBC, which in 99% of cases it will be, this also connects the school to the NEN, which has many school resources available. Also, video conferencing is provided by all RBCs (gate keepers etc... cost money). Plus other services.
So, overall, yes, school internet connections are expensive, but for many good reasons. However, £8k for a 10Mbit connection should be leading the school to look elsewhere to compare - for the same level of service.
Last edited by localzuk; 1st February 2012 at 09:53 PM.
6 Thanks to localzuk:
elsiegee40 (1st February 2012), enjay (6th February 2012), glennda (1st February 2012), GrumbleDook (1st February 2012), Rawns (2nd February 2012), synaesthesia (2nd February 2012)
1st February 2012, 09:44 PM #13
@misources, can you let us know what position it is you hold at your school? This is quite important so we can point you in the right direction as it seems you are unaware of many legal and practical issues when it comes to school internet connections and information hosting (both file and email). Mainly legal emphasis it must be said.
1st February 2012, 09:48 PM #14
- Rep Power
Can you send me the links to other posts? Would love to read.
Originally Posted by Dos_Box
As for your points....contention is largely a fallacy. When I test my home connection at various times of the day, I get 100MB during the working day, and around 40MB in the evening, so what's more important is what you actually recieve. Peak broadband usage is in the evening. So a school at ten a.m. on my line would get 100MB down, 10MB up. "Guaranteed" speed? So a school should pay 20x the amount I do to have someone TELL them a service is guaranteed? Not sure I get that, sorry. And the legal, safety, privacy issues is the one I know least about, but as I understand it, there are a lot of suppliers of filtering out there and it's very competitive, and certainly not enough to bump up the service to 20x what I'm paying for at home.
1st February 2012, 09:51 PM #15
@LocalZuk has hit the nail on the head.
Hotmail and Gmail are great - yes free but not centrally managed - Live@edu/Google Apps have only recently been created to enable this central management which is key.
Could you imagiene having to try and manually look after 1800 hotmail mailboxs? I've got over 2000 mailboxes on my two exchange servers - but again this functionality costs money but the man hours needed to 1800 hotmail boxes would take the cost 10 fold most probably
By Jona in forum How do you do....it?
Last Post: 21st March 2011, 02:35 PM
By stevenwba in forum Windows
Last Post: 6th May 2010, 09:59 PM
By tigger19 in forum Internet Related/Filtering/Firewall
Last Post: 11th March 2009, 11:38 PM
By tigger19 in forum Wireless Networks
Last Post: 11th March 2009, 07:42 AM
By TechSupp in forum General Chat
Last Post: 9th November 2007, 06:46 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Tags for this Thread