I believe that the HP v19xx is based on the 3com 29xx series.
Last edited by mrbios; 4th May 2013 at 08:14 PM.
HP V1910 == ex 3Com 2928/2952 Baseline SFP Plus == rebranded H3C S5120-SI (with some softwarelocks, i.e. no IRF stacking, no "official" CLI): nice feature set, but with loud fans. For the price itīs a bargain.
HP 1810 == Itīs HP lowcost really basic managable switch, but without "Procurve OS" (which you have on e.g. 25XX, 3500/3800/5400/8200), something else, almost no features, but fanless. For that price you can have other fanless switches with more features (No, not the Cisco/Linksys SG300 of course. And no, I havenīt that Zxyel GS1910, or that DLink DGS-1210, so I cannot say anything about them. So, this is only about looking at the datasheets)
also look at Ciscoīs "comparison":
http://www.cisco.com/en/US/prod/coll...comparison.pdf, although I do not believe everything printed there.
Last edited by snoerre; 4th May 2013 at 08:44 PM.
Not that it should matter. The majority of primary schools out this way have been running on 3com 4400's for the last decade without them dropping a beat. I wouldn't rate 3com any less than HP back in the day!
- Before that 3Com rebranded some of the H3C switches, not all, e.g. the 3Com 2924 SFP Plus is not based upon H3Cīs Comware operating system, as I remember; (the HP V1910 is and the mentioned HP E4800 == 3Com 4800G == H3C S5500-EI) So, there are H3C switches that have never had any "3Com" label onboard. Be careful if you say "5500": There was indeed a 3Com 5500, which was sold as HP E5500, but this one has nothing to do with the HP A5500 series. The 3Com 5500 was a relabeled H3C S5600 I think. Understood?
- Then we have all H3C switches: H3C - Technical Support & Documents Software Download The switches you mentioned above belong to H3C. But not all switches mentioned on the H3C homepage are sold worldwide with an HP (software/Hardware) label attached)
- And we have HPīs "old" "Procurve" labeled switches which they sold before they overtook 3Com/H3C. (Btw, HP is adjusting its old "Procurve" based switches so you can use H3Cīs CLI syntax there.)
Now, I think HP calls all its switches "HP Networking" and distinguishes between "V","E" and "A" series.
The only thing you can make out what is what is by reading the release notes. H3C based switches have Comware operating system and therefore have CMW310 (Comware version 3.10), CMW520 (Comware version 5.20) and CMW710 (Comware version 7.10) while the Procurve ones have e.g. K.13, K.14, K.15.* labels.
Last edited by snoerre; 4th May 2013 at 09:50 PM.
CyberNerd (4th May 2013)
I have one of the cheaper H3C switches in my HP fabric which I bought by mistake, (sold as HP Baseline 2928) never again will I make such a mistake, its a real PIA I wish I had read the specs better before I bought it.
Making it work properly with our 8 HP VLans has been problematic and it complains bitterly on its uplink back to the core with far too many error frames yet If I put an HP26xxx or even a Netgear in its place everything everything else is sweet,
We have thrown every update at it, used SFPs and copper for uplinking and its still rubbish.
I know 3Com made good switches but these things are complete *$Ĩ......
I would never have knowingly bought it, that's why it's ended up in a far reaching corner of the network where it doesn't require a lot of configuration and only has 4 devices and an uplink.
The usual apples, buy cheap buy twice..
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)