Thin Client and Virtual Machines Thread, Best way forward - Virtulisation in Technical; Originally Posted by fiza
Thats a spanner in the works!! To SAN or not to SAN. That is the question!!!
21st June 2012, 04:53 PM #31
I don't know how hyper-v works in this respect but i know with vmware at least if a host dies, you could literally use anything that'll run the hypervisor to bring those machines back online or bring them back online on another host instantly (of which your physical boxes would be powerful enough to run it all on one without issue) whereas if you're hosting them locally you're relying on backups.....now obviously if your SAN dies you again need to restore from backup, but if you have two SANs and multiple hosts you can restore those backups to the other san or host and have them back up and running instantly again......thus the benefit of multiple SANs.
Originally Posted by fiza
21st June 2012, 04:56 PM #32
If you want Free HA, then the XEN hypervisor on another platform ( Citrix Xen is just a rehash of the opensource XEN hypervisor) such as SUSE can be made to do HA. Not looked at it for a long time though.
You can even build a VM to be your "test" storage server .
21st June 2012, 04:59 PM #33
Openfiler ( opensource san ) can do HA, not tied it but if somone wants to demonstrate to senior MGMT then it would be cool to show them the full resiliance a bit of ££££ will get them..
Originally Posted by mrbios
We have 2 HP Lefthand Sans to "Hopefully" rely on.
21st June 2012, 05:01 PM #34
We do have old servers but these are the ones running the Network at the moment and that I want to virtualise.
Originally Posted by twin--turbo
21st June 2012, 05:03 PM #35
Hey I am not meaning to put spanners in the works there is a lot of good advice around, and I am not saying "DO NOT EVER USE A SAN", just letting you know that SANS(s) are not the be all and end all for either uptime or performance, I've been there and done that and when it came to replacing our SANS, I just simply decided not to replace them at all.
I had two SANS, one of them failed catastophically within 3 years. Deep down, I couldn't then trust the other one either even though it did stay up until I decomissioned it. I've had tens of physical hosts over the years and i've only ever lost one outright. Thats not a good ratio for the SANS and I hear about problems with SANS and NAS's in other schools in my area all the time.
If you can justify spending th £££'s going for the full on 99.9999% uptime then by all means go for it. I couldnt justify it based on the fact that my budgets are being cut year on year and some years I have not even been able to have a technician. When we couldn't afford a £15k technician I could not justify spending £15k on SANS.
21st June 2012, 05:08 PM #36
@AButters - (Sorry to thread hijack) What manufacturer was your SAN? (Tier 1? Sun, LeftHand, NetAPP, EMC?)
I'm intrigued by those Infortrend boxes... they're mega-cheap!
21st June 2012, 05:09 PM #37
Tier 1. That's all your gonna get out of me sorry
21st June 2012, 05:11 PM #38
21st June 2012, 05:13 PM #39
Ahhh i can relate to the "catastrophe = deep down can never trust again" position (never touching a motherboard made by MSI again put it that way!... nearly set fire to an IT room!) Though i think one day you'll reconsider as the benefits are there, you've just been a bit unlucky
Originally Posted by AButters
Anything you want to know? We've had 4 + 1 JBOD in the time i've been here (ALL still running, 1 about to be decommissioned for being 7 years old)
Originally Posted by pantscat
Last edited by mrbios; 21st June 2012 at 05:14 PM.
21st June 2012, 05:17 PM #40
Go on ebay and spend £100 on a Poweredge 2800/2850 with 8-10GB of ram and a couple of 143GB disks. You may even get 2 servers and more power for your £100.
Originally Posted by fiza
Build a test environment and don't waste thousands on stuff untill your sure your happy with what's going on.
Theres other costs that will mount up, L3 switch, UPS, Backup device.
21st June 2012, 05:24 PM #41
Dell PowerEdge 1850 1U server, ideal terminal/web server | eBay
Bit of extra ram for £10 and you haev a smart little virtual host for 2-3 servers or more if your frugal on the specs
21st June 2012, 05:45 PM #42
Last edited by mrbios; 21st June 2012 at 05:46 PM.
21st June 2012, 05:53 PM #43
Depends on the hypervisor you want to use as hyper-v won't work on the PE2800 or PE1850 plus a load others.
21st June 2012, 07:25 PM #44
A recent 64Bit Desktop ( anything in the last 4 years or so ) will also most likly support Various Hypervisors, I have run Vmware and Citrix Xen on a Dell Optiplex 740 , Lenovo Athalon X2 64 ( on an ITX board USFF pC ).
21st June 2012, 07:56 PM #45
Interesting discussions here, and some of you guys have an IT budget that would put a banking corporation to shame.
I'm in kinda same position really. I do appreciate the benefits of virtualisation but I'm of the attitude that it needs to be done properly if you are going to bung all your servers into a SAN, that is DOUBLE up on everything for redundancy. I've recently priced up a very nice 3 host and SAN with fibre switch, and even utilising my existing equipment the whole project was approaching £30k+ which very hard to justify to Bursar when to him it looks like 4 boxes and a shed load of cables lol. So back to what Abutters mentioned using local hosts and good backups...this might be better solution for some. It's also setting up realistic expectations with SLAs with the SMTs, although in truth all this will go out of the window when they can't host a class due to 1 hour downtime.
So I'm on a crossroad as well .... Does one choose a well designed VM+ SAN ? Local storage with VMs ? Go back to old school, single servers with good backups? Maybe looking at important servers in the school(fileservers,exchange,sql) and clustering those?
Last edited by MrWu; 21st June 2012 at 07:57 PM.
By ChrisH in forum Windows
Last Post: 11th March 2013, 08:45 PM
By plexer in forum Hardware
Last Post: 6th January 2010, 01:13 PM
By Cyber-Dude in forum Courses and Training
Last Post: 7th July 2006, 08:47 PM
By tosca925 in forum How do you do....it?
Last Post: 12th December 2005, 10:45 PM
By mac_shinobi in forum Wireless Networks
Last Post: 27th September 2005, 02:40 AM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)