We have the sun odt plugin installed sitewide.
Sun ODF Plugin for Microsoft Office - Get It
and we already have hundreds of ODT files onsite so it would be really simple to switch. (a reg key sets it as default save format
The blatant SIMS lock-in is the only technical reason we keep MSOffice. All teaching depts we spoke to have no problem with using OOO instead.
Eventually MSOffice will wither on the vine as it becomes less relevant. Most people don't know the difference, and the ones that do soon see Ooo has more features that interest them than MSOffice (2003) anyway - I mean the actual useful features like save to pdf, convert to wiki format, use a mysql database rather than having a facelift.
HodgeHi (4th November 2008)
From a management point of view OO has a long way to go on windows and OSX. The ADM version is not free is it?
Even Office and iwork can be configured with managed preferences on OS X.
One thing to consider also is what would replace outlook if you stripped Office out?
Web based email stuff is okay but its not as fancy as full outlook and our staff hated OWA to use all the time.
You could use pop/imap mode in some clients but its not as good as full outlook I believe.
I am all for office 2007, I think its amazing and well worth the cash as it will generally improve productivity for most. I have never been amazed with OO and I just see it as okay. I know people that hate it when working with tables in the Writer part as they have layout issues etc where as office was a breeze.
EDIT: El' reg has a review of it for linux now http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/11..._dot_o_review/
We pay nothing to use Zimbra - it is free open-source software. The server hardware cost just under £2,000.
Zimbra is expensive (for push email parts - yes we do need push email) and would require replacing exchange in our situation and thats before we get to the fact yahoo own it and I hate yahoo junk with a passion. They will stitch you all in the end (my conspiracy theory there)
Zimbra also is not exactly as fully featured as outlook but they are limited by ajax tbh as certain things just wont work due to the way IE etc security is. One big thing I suppose is you cant do a mail merge email.
We have been using OpenOffice and OpenDocument for the last 2 years.
It is easy to do if you aren't already locked-in to technologies like Exchange, VB, SIMS or some of the proprietary VLEs.
I'd love to move away from MSO but unfortunately OOo is just not as good as MSOXP/2003 for usability (I HATE 2007) and it is quite clear it was designed by a coder, not a designer. Also as we use exchange, we are tied to Outlook.
If OOo want to replace MSO then they have to either get a fully working Outlook replacement, or an exchange replacement.
SaaS is never good enough for most heavy users. so AJAX/Silverlight/etc are no good.
Last edited by Midget; 5th November 2008 at 10:58 AM.
Just to go off at a slight angle, MS have announced that Office 14 will be available either as a series of advert funded web apps (free?) or via a subscription model
Obviously competing with Google Apps but may mean that folk stick with Microsoft
We've been installing OOo alongside MS Office, Now that I see that ADm for OOo we can control it better.
We only install Outlook for certain users, usually, when they need to have two logons to the email server (reception staff: their own, and the general one). We always found that Outlook never quite coped with running on wireless laptops, it went offline, and never came back. The Mdaemon server we have has a "lookout" theme that looks very much like outlook, so keeps them happy.
OOo is also missing a publisher clone... or even something that would open .pub files.
I still have to pop back into excel, when I need to do any importing, but this is because I don't know it well enough. I am being subtly subversive, OOo is installed everywhere now, and so I personally create files with it, and when people ask, that's what they get the odt, file, not the .doc equivalent.
I've opened some of my word documents in Open Office writer and some documents especially if they contain a lot of pictures lose their formatting so open office just is not viable for me.
I would love to move away from Office to OOo but there are just too many issues to resolve: staff retraining, compatibility with sharepoint, features etc. etc.
This issue is part of a whole wider dilemma for me - to open source or not to open source? I'd love to, but my instinct is it's not quite there yet....
I installed OO in all my schools when I first started working in them many moons ago.
Out of 12 - only 1 said they didn't want it and preferred to pay for MS Office and 1 other "reverted" after 2 years when 2 new teachers turned up and said they couldn't work with it
I install it on all pupil machines and give the teachers MS office.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)