*nix Thread, Linux mail server, Blackberry Enterprise Server, GMV Atlas - few questions in Technical; @ SYNACK
I agree/disagree. I've used BES and one thing I can relate to is the logs. They are rubbish. ...
11th May 2011, 04:30 PM #16
I agree/disagree. I've used BES and one thing I can relate to is the logs. They are rubbish. However, it does what it's supposed to. Works nicely and like with every product there are good/bad points.
Support I've had has been extremly good. Not sure on your experience. When I call RIM, I get an anser straight away.
Another option to use Exch is you can use EAS (active-synch) which is covered by your CAL. There's a pluggin for so that BB can use it too. No need for any addtional infrastructure.
11th May 2011, 04:34 PM #17
I'd assume the external server is your own, and was using a secure method to obtain emails from the one inside the firewall. You're right, though, it would probably be a mistake to export your internal email to Google's servers - your email should stay under your control.
Originally Posted by GrumbleDook
Equally, it would be a mistake to assume that anything behind your firewall is safe and not properly secure servers - many schools have little protection against people plugging in whatever devices they can sneak in and running port scanners or similar.
11th May 2011, 04:42 PM #18
Thanks @sukh Good to hear that it can work, I have had my fill of BES though and would need to be medicated heavily to even consider going near it again. It is possibly one of the worst things that I have ever dealt with in IT and I would put it right up there with SBS 2003 on the list of worst products in existance. As to support I don't think that they even know NZ exists, they can't find a 100 year old street on their address verification system. I can only hope that other solutions continue to crush it out of existance at the current rate so that I never have the misfortune of encountering it again.
Originally Posted by sukh
11th May 2011, 04:43 PM #19
Simple mirroring failover (your mail server hardware conks out, another takes over) should be handled by your virtualisation solution. For larger installations, I imagine mySQL has a mirroring / load balancing solution. I seem to remember my home email server being file system based, so I guess that would just use a distributed file system for storage.
Originally Posted by sukh
Sorry, meant comparing Exchange (any version) with other email servers.
There's a big performance improvement from 2003, in terms on IOPS
Would Sendmail or similar use some kind of post-processing script or regular expression to do the same thing?
You have transport rules which can be implemented
11th May 2011, 04:44 PM #20
+1 - When you using BES, it's secure all the way up to your BES router, from here, the next hop os the BES NOC, which again is secure. Then to your device.
Also, you do have control, what control dont you have, if you dont, then I'd choose the appropiate 3rd party.
11th May 2011, 04:59 PM #21
If we're talking just about Exchange then we have HA here, if we bring virtualisation into this, then we're looking at something completly different.
If you have virtualisation deployed then yes, this can work, however if you dont then this brings in extra costs. Also, normal virtualisation (depends on what vendor you are using),you have to buy additional licenses to activate or use this feature. Even then, you will need some sort of replication between the two hosts, if using a SAN, then you will need further software, and possibly a license to use replications.
Even comparing Exch with other servers, I have just mentioed a few things here. The amount of users on an Exchange platform has to be a reason why it's chosen. Even live@edu which I see many schools are using runs off Exchange.
I'm not too sure how Send mail, cant comment. But you can use regular expressions with Exch.
11th May 2011, 05:01 PM #22
@dhicks - You can do most things that you can do with exchange using free software, you just need to use a lot of it. Exchange is all in one nice bundle proven and designed to work right together under one unified system with one config and one standard. To accomplish even part of this functionality you would need to couple sendmail with a backend DB, this with the ability to be block mirrored to another server and to another drive on the same server. You would need calanders from another bit of software, contacts and tasks storage along with a system to process mailbox rules at the server all linked back into the databases. You would also need a system to seurely mirror just logon details and password hashes to and external database that could run on a different system in a DMZ. This is not even touching on the autocomplete functions, the very competent webmail which is a massive improvement from 2003. You would also need to look to add in a whole Astrix phone system backend to handle voice messages, voice recognition to transcribe voicemail and text to speech to read them out. Add in Activesync support which you would need to liscence and you have a massive pile of free software tacked together in all sorts of ways making it unsuportable by anyone but its creator and probably a nightmare to troubleshoot.
There are solutions that do provide a good subset of these features but in general even though they are based on free software some of the nice aditional features like the far superior (in comparision to IMAP and POP3) Activsync protocol are only in the pay for versions.
11th May 2011, 05:29 PM #23
Still using Atlas and IMAP, the software is looking more promising - though it's struggling a bit with the idle capability (which is listed as a capability of IMAP on that port). If I can get past this, I may get somewhere!
Last edited by 3s-gtech; 11th May 2011 at 05:40 PM.
12th May 2011, 01:26 PM #24
Seems that idle isn't working properly - it can enter the idle state using telnet, but doesn't receive the done call when a new message arrives. Not sure why yet.
19th May 2011, 01:44 PM #25
- Rep Power
One of the steps of the Atlas installer can help you because it checks the configuration of SMTP, IMAP and Administrator data account according to the data inserted during the setup process (this step is named Registration and verification), there you can see the checklist results for the IMAP, SMTP and IDLE.
Originally Posted by 3s-gtech
There are some logs that may be useful under C:\Program Files\GMV\Atlas\Logs\aaaammdd_Atlas\YOURMACHINE_RE VXXXX_AtlasSetup_PIDXXXX_main.log, there is also a forum for technical questions in Atlas GMV web site
By Craig_W in forum Netbooks, PDA and Phones
Last Post: 5th August 2010, 01:23 PM
By EduTech in forum Netbooks, PDA and Phones
Last Post: 3rd August 2010, 01:23 PM
By TYO in forum Netbooks, PDA and Phones
Last Post: 23rd July 2010, 04:20 PM
By browolf in forum Netbooks, PDA and Phones
Last Post: 2nd July 2010, 10:40 AM
By googlemad in forum Windows Server 2000/2003
Last Post: 13th August 2009, 02:19 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)