Re-networking the network

[Stuart_C]

I'm really just talking out load here and would like some input.

When I started working here many years ago our network configuration consisted of two networks connected via a router (PC). Our, larger, accademic network and a much smaller one for our Finance department and some of the sercretaries. This worked as it kept our pupil records sepearte from the main school and provided a layer of security becuase you couldn't see the finance network from the accademic.

Times have moved on now and resources like SIMS and PASS are required on both networks. Files are spread accross many servers and users require access to all the resources, Trust relationships exist between both domains. All sorts of people want to do training in different rooms and so on.

So baring in mind that my Finance network consists of only about 20 users, I'm starrting to feel that I don't gain anything be having two networks. The security component has gone and all I'm left with is the added complications of security, seperate AD's, Group Policy, scripts. Routing is a bit of a pain as well. Generally I don't think I get any benefit compared to a large number of downsides and the removal of the "finance" server and replacing it with another DC for my accademic domain looks very sasty. A bit of re-cabling to put everything on one physical network and Boom! Done. Easier admin and management and usability for staff moving round the College.

Is there anything I may be missing?

[DAZZD88]

Would setting up VLANs not effectively give you what you have now but on the same physical network?

[Stuart_C]

The point is to get rid of what I have. I don't think I get any benefit. I jsut wanted to talk it through with some experts to see if I'm missing anything.

[cpjitservices]

I'd put everything on the same network so your ACAD, and Finance and then setup some VLANS.

[IanT]

VLANS is the way to go.