Hardware Thread, i-Pad vs Laptop in Technical; Its that
word that's the Elephant in the Room
Do we lock the the sharp implements away or do ...
13th August 2012, 11:56 AM #76
Its that word that's the Elephant in the Room
Do we lock the the sharp implements away or do we just put them in a draw and say don't touch - discuss
Do we lock everything in the safe overnight (or course we do with the money or a childs medical records) but we don't put their excercise books (with teachers comments) in there as well
IDG Tech News
13th August 2012, 02:30 PM #77
Sorry to everyone for quoting this in full, but it's worth a re-read just for the spelling and grammar mistakes.
Originally Posted by SYNACK
So anyway, what have i done to annoy you SYNACK. All I've done is describe a system that works, in a school that works, where different members of staff get along and respect one another. Obviously not your school then. Then after I've described our system I've defended it against criticism from others on here without trying too hard to attack their way of doing things (or at least, trying not too much).
So, I've never said teachers are gods. Also, I haven't whined about anything - I'm very happy where I work and the system & people (whether teachers or not) I work with. I even like the kids and look forward to going to work each day. Again, doesn't sound much like you. As for having a "cavalier disregard for copyright" if you read what I wrote, beyond saying some copyright issues are a grey area I explicitly said it was wrong to download youtube videos which was what the whole discussion was about.
However, two things I strongly feel about are as follows:
1) whether things such as youtube are blocked in a school should be a curriculum/leadership issue, not a tech issue
2) a mindset where you expect the worst of the people you work with, and set up systems on that basis, is generally a self-fulfilling expectation
I have been reading (and contributing) to these forums for about four years and have learnt quite a lot technically of which I am quite grateful. I have even directed the tech staff at school towards here as the forums are a great resource.
One thing that is striking when reading the forums is the level of disdain that seems to exist across schools in the UK. A common theme in many posts (usually not all at once) is that the kids are odious little vandals that can't be trusted with anything (searching for "scrotes" or "gits" throws up lots of results); teachers are idiots, borderline psychotic and generally have no idea about anything and don't deserve a job; SMT have been promoted up the ladder in inverse proportion to their competency; and local authorities have no idea about what really goes on in schools.
So if you work in a school where you're nodding "yes!" to all those things I imagine the sentiments directed back towards you are somewhat similar and school would bring about a certain siege mentality. Must be a lot of unpleasantness in a lot of your schools. So in one sense I understand that when I have expressed a reasonably mild disagreement on some aspects of network management from the point of view of a user I get strident criticism. But that's OK - I'm looking forward to going to work tomorrow. Are you?
Last edited by rdk; 13th August 2012 at 02:57 PM.
13th August 2012, 03:06 PM #78
Yes ... that is the key word and where our technical expertise and the managerial / leadership expertise of various people (in a number of cases this will include us) to deal with it, but it is not much different to how we have to deal with H&S for science labs, PE, School trips ... building infrastructure, contract management, etc ... and you get some good schools and some bad schools doing it.
Originally Posted by SimpleSi
If people want specific risk assessment courses for security of technology then BCS do a number of good ones, including where you learn how to compromise depending on the sector you work in. To some extent it is very much like project management. Go and do PRINCE2 foundation and you learn the terms and tools ... do the practitioner and you learn how to apply it and when to bend things, or even ignore things (and before anyone jumps up at me saying 'ignore things' please think back to what I have said about the compromise between technical and organisational responses to security / data protection / etc).
Some people appear risk adverse because the environments they work in have a number of high probability factors or high impact factors and they have to take appropriate action, sometimes to the detriment of other aspects of the business. The institute then has to decide to address the risks or change how the business operates ... or ... work out a compromise for both. Some people appear risk adverse because they do not have the time, the resources, the expertise, the will or the position within the institute to try to achieve a workable compromise position. For these ... I would simply suggest that explaining why it doesn't / wouldn't work for them is the best option and accepting that others will have a different position. It is not that you are wrong ... or others are more right ... just different positions.
As for the techie / teacher thing ... please remember that this sort of things happens everywhere. Ask a squaddie what he/she thinks of someone from the RAF and you get one view. Ask a tankie what they think of pay clerks ... ask what a civil servant thinks of an MP ... again, it is not that others don't know how the other part live and work, a good number do and are supportive and can even do it themselves ... and we are always going to hear about the negative more than the good stuff ... we just need to "accentuate the positive" to quote a certain Mr Crosby.
20th August 2012, 05:45 PM #79
Personally, I'd still go for laptops or netbooks.
Yes, I like my tablet but for browsing, messing about - not doing actual work.
The biggest fundamental problem with tablets (in my own opinion) is: -
1). They make you work slower. I don't care who you are - whatever you are doing on your tablet is going to be done slower and more restricted than if you had a mouse and keyboard. I will give you a race at writing a paragraph of text then selecting the second letter in the fourth word and deleting it, then continuing the paragraph at the end. If they slow you down doing your work, they can't be good for you, no matter how cool it is to swipe stuff with a finger. When I'm using a tablet I feel like a caveman. Yes, you feel modern but there's a time and a place for them and only as a nicety at the moment - for viewing things, browsing things but not doing work things. A Primary School audience would probably be the best place for browsing big pictures, videos, playing an educational game or two (if flash works).
2). Keyboard - Laptops have a keyboard. You can type much quicker with one and typing is surely something that's important for school work.
3). Software - Everything is useable on a laptop. With tablets, certain sites are just not ready for them yet. Many places that require WYSIWYG editors have alternatives or nothing at all. You get issues with Flash, PDF downloads (the lack of embedding etc). I'm not saying tablets are useless - it's just that personnaly I think educational sites are just not ready for them yet - maybe another year or two. For convenience sake everything just works on a laptop because the operating system has been around such a long time that well know applications have chugged along with it and solidified. With tablets, all of those well known apps are having to reinvent themselves to try and work in a new way and there's still a learning curve going on.
Again, that's just my opinion.
From a work point of view, a laptop is still the way to go to get things done quickly and without the hassle of "lack of support" in various situations.
Last edited by mylearningltd; 20th August 2012 at 05:48 PM.
Reason: I'm a DIV
11th October 2012, 09:05 AM #80
- Rep Power
for less required ways to use i opt to laptops especially when it comes to personal use..
Originally Posted by Gibson335
By Jollity in forum Hardware
Last Post: 29th June 2012, 09:00 AM
By Simcfc73 in forum Hardware
Last Post: 4th September 2011, 11:50 PM
By maniac in forum Hardware
Last Post: 20th May 2009, 02:51 PM
By eean in forum Hardware
Last Post: 12th December 2007, 10:36 AM
By Geoff in forum Hardware
Last Post: 26th August 2005, 06:50 AM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)