Broken laptop screen

[LeMarchand]

Has anyone ever managed to get a warranty repair on a laptop screen that "just broke" (not dropped etc - honest!)?

Has anyone even had this happen?

Hints & tips appreciated...

[SYSMAN_MK]

Had dell replace a couple with no problems.

[buzzard]

TBH I'd be surprised as there must have been some form of pressure to cause the issue, now if there was a defect in the screen that meant the pressure could have been alot lesss before failure is a different question, however, getting that proven is another question, just out of intrest whats the make manufacturer?

[Tyiell]

We had one with a dodgy inverter - it died within a few weeks of purchase. Pretty sure it was a Dell Latitude - it was replaced on warranty - no quibble

I've also had an HP delivered with a dodgy hdd. They were crap on the phone, but once I'd played the waiting 10 minutes to be transferred 100 times, they also repaired with no charge.

I believe you get a 1 year manufacturers warranty on all hardware and suppliers are obliged to honour it - it doesn't even cost them, because they claim from manufacturers, so they're normally happy enough. The only trouble I've ever had is with extended warranties - some companies try their best to avoid honouring those!!

[LeMarchand]

TBH I'd be surprised as there must have been some form of pressure to cause the issue, now if there was a defect in the screen that meant the pressure could have been alot lesss before failure is a different question, however, getting that proven is another question, just out of intrest whats the make manufacturer?

That was my thinking (hopefully the owner will take a bit more care in the future - though as they left their last machine on a seat in the staffroom and returned to find it dented on the floor, maybe not). It's a Dell, so SYSMAN's reply gives me a bit of hope...

[LeMarchand]

We had one with a dodgy inverter - it died within a few weeks of purchase. Pretty sure it was a Dell Latitude - it was replaced on warranty - no quibble

I've also had an HP delivered with a dodgy hdd. They were crap on the phone, but once I'd played the waiting 10 minutes to be transferred 100 times, they also repaired with no charge.

Sorry, should have made it clear; I've yet to see the machine, but it sounds like a cracked screen rather than a hardware fault. Though I'd best check...

[nephilim]

I had one that whilst I was repairing a software fault the screen just cracked. I felt the screen, and it was burning hot, so I could only assume far too much power was going to it.

[broc]

We have had a number of DELL Laptop screens replaced under warranty, the defects were not related to cracks or leakage though.

We once tried to crack a screen as a test by deliberately mishandling (it was from a very old, broken system destined for WEEE disposal). it took a lot of effort, much more than we expected.

[LeMarchand]

I secretly suspect user damage, but at least it doesn't sound like it would be impossible to get sorted under warranty (they've had them less than a week!).

[bertster]

Also had Dell replace two on the same laptop within warranty - no problem

Dell also replaced a screen that failed 2 months after the warranty expired (XPS M530). Took me a while to persuade them to fix it though!

[rad]

If its a Dell, you can try and get them to send you a replacement part and you to fit it yourself. Other manufacturers you have to send it away for them to fix. I have had an HP laptop that was sent to Europe, and then back via DHL (or whoever) and no doubt cos £££ in postage alone

[srochford]

Other manufacturers you have to send it away for them to fix. I have had an HP laptop that was sent to Europe, and then back via DHL (or whoever) and no doubt cos £££ in postage alone

Pretty sure that HP will have done sums which say "it costs £x more to ship to/from country X than to ship within the UK but wages are £y lower so the total bill is less" and, just sneaking in politics for a bit, that's partly why there are so many unemployed people in the UK - they get paid more than people elsewhere in Europe or Asia and multinationals like HP can make bigger profits by not using UK employees.

[FN-GM]

As others say if its Dell you will be ok. I have had many dell laptop keybaords replaced when the students pull the keys off.