Hardware Thread, Dell or HP in Technical; Originally Posted by SYNACK
HP for servers and desktops, I have had a bad run with Dells, they can't all ...
7th June 2010, 07:39 PM #16
Just quickly checked our helldesk, with 520 Dell desktops we've had 6 hardware faults in total in the last 5 years, out of 120 laptops 3 hardware faults in the same period excluding some batteries which had expired out of warranty (8 of them), no server faults at all. Every single one was repaired with 1 working day.
Originally Posted by SYNACK
HP - out of 60 desktops, 17 hardware faults, quickest repaired next day, longest took 23 days. Laptops, out of 20, 7 faults, quickest repaired in 4 days, longest took 7 months. HP Switches, 4 switch hardware faults, 3 replaced within 2 days, one took 17 days as their support techs were being useless, also had 5 mini-gbic fibre modules fail.
IDG Tech News
7th June 2010, 08:20 PM #17
I have no brand loyalty in terms of desktops or laptops but find i can never get Dell's pricing to match HP in terms of like for like kit, i.e recently the HP elite 8100 vs the OptiPlex 980 was about £80 per unit in favour of HP (same motherboards/ chipset, processor, RAM, warranty etc). In terms of reliability i brought 150 odd Lenovo M58's last year and have not had a single niggle and the build quality is excellent, that said i would not buy them again as they messed as around with delivery dates. Switches Procurve all the way, some of the Dells look good on paper but you must keep warranties up to scratch to get software updates & servers there isnt alot between Dell & HP although Dell's line up does seem to cater on the face of it more to virtualized environments.
7th June 2010, 08:26 PM #18
We're in the same position as teejay, 605 Dell Desktops we have had 2 Motherboards, both Ultra Small Form Factors and both refused to detect DVD drives, and one HDD. All were replaced next business day. Of the 50 Dell laptops we have had one motherboard failure, suspect water spill after seeing the state of the chassis, but Dell replaced no questions asked and one LCD inverter failed, again both next working day.
I inherited 56 HP desktops, without any extended warranty and they cost loads in replacement part before I swapped them out with Dells last summer.
We have a mix of Dell HP and IBM servers, in terms of reliability we have had no problems with either the Dells or HP units, but the IBMs have been really temperamental, and Parts take days to turn up. We have 4hr engineer on site response on the Dell servers and next day telephone support on the HP and IBM servers.
I have a great relationship with my Dell Account team, I get invites to all their technical seminars (luckily only 20 minute drive to their offices from home) and last week we went to their Executive Briefing Centre, to have a play with their new technology, including the Dell Streak, before it’s official release date. But it’s their support that I have found sells it for me, even with the issues of the Indian call centre, we have found that the email support, gets around the queuing and language problems.
Hope it doesn't sound too soap boxy....
7th June 2010, 08:45 PM #19
Yes, agree on the switches, the HP Procurves are far superior to the Dell ones.
Originally Posted by Tallwood_6
7th June 2010, 10:18 PM #20
I would take Dell over HP any day on everything but switches, although I have my gripes over ProCurve as well (two warranty replacements in the last 6 months, the latest one took 3 WEEKS for them to ship the replacement due to stock issues).
I don't like HP's product design much - they seem to have a fetish for using as many different sizes of screws as possible, and in quantities that are about 3 times higher than the equivalent Dell computer would use. As someone who has to sometimes take apart said machines, that annoys me a lot.
On the support side, every single time I have called an HP support number that wasn't for ProCurve, I have had astronomically bad service. I understand from the above posts that this isn't typical, but it's been pretty consistent for me. Dell support has been so good to me that I cannot recall a single instance in more than 4 years that I have been dissatisfied with them.
On the flipside, Dell's schools account team are sometimes very hard to work with. Account manager quality seems to very greatly. If you go the Dell route, I would recommend either going through a reseller, or getting Premier Page access sorted for your account as a priority to make life a lot easier on yourself.
Last edited by AngryTechnician; 7th June 2010 at 10:24 PM.
Reason: Dell support
7th June 2010, 10:35 PM #21
HP here. Good pricing, good support in my experience. I've never actually had to phone them for support - I always use their support website to submit tickets, and 90% of the time, they organise collection of faulty devices next day without question. The other 10% of the time required clarifications of my requests, followed by them sorting out the replacements etc...
7th June 2010, 11:31 PM #22
Server - moving to all HP (great support from the 1 call I've made)
Desktops - Stone (good after sales for years)
Laptops - Stone / HP (both had issues)
Switches - Cisco (under a support contract)
Never used Dell - yet.
8th June 2010, 12:16 AM #23
HP any day
Currently moving to HP Desktops campus wide
Already have HP Laptops where we have them
All new Servers have been HP since I started
Switches are Netgear and Cisco mixed
Media Converters are Allied Tesyis
8th June 2010, 11:53 AM #24
I'm a Dell fan tbh....
We've got a mix of Dell Optiplex 755/760's and older G/SX240/260/280's. In fairness the older kit has its niggles but nothing that a well placed whack can't fix. I've only had two 755's fail in three years and they we're replaced next business day.
I've also got 70 HP DX5150's that give no end of problems. They were purchased prior to my starting and on had 12 months warranty . So far 10 have had motherboard failures and 3 hard drives. I'm finding that they like to overheat... a lot. even when they've been air dustered too.
Servers are a mix of HP Proliant and Dell Poweredge and our switches are all Cisco.
8th June 2010, 11:59 AM #25
Wow - you're putting ALL your trust in one good support call?!
Originally Posted by steve
@OP: We have HP and Dell servers here. Both work fine, but Dell was better value for money. Wouldn't buy HP workstations again after a bad experience with a class load of them.
8th June 2010, 12:03 PM #26
HP for switches. Dell for PCs. (bit pricey though) I have 33 Dells that are now 5 years old and have only had two faults in all that time. I must admit, I buy from a reseller so I don't know about Dell sales, but I have never had a problem with the support and have found them very helpful. Then again, I haven't rung them for a long time due to the relibility of their product so that may have all changed!
I am looking at new machines ATM and I cannot afford the Dells this time - so probably unbadged or HP
By TheLibrarian in forum Hardware
Last Post: 21st April 2010, 11:08 AM
By bladedanny in forum Our Advertisers
Last Post: 18th March 2010, 03:45 PM
Last Post: 15th March 2010, 10:17 PM
By Robbocop in forum Netbooks, PDA and Phones
Last Post: 4th February 2010, 10:41 AM
By GrumbleDook in forum Bad Experiences
Last Post: 30th June 2006, 10:51 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)