Hardware Thread, Multiple USB scanners on same host PC? in Technical; If funds will allow look at purchasing a network scanner, plug it into the network and then no PC needed, ...
10th February 2010, 02:33 AM #16
If funds will allow look at purchasing a network scanner, plug it into the network and then no PC needed, scan direct to user folders, we use Fujitsu scanners for this purpose.
10th February 2010, 08:59 AM #17
Not at all, there are enough standard USB ports on computers these days (even those from several years ago) to accomodate the quantity of scanners i'd be looking to use
Originally Posted by Arthur
Originally Posted by srochford
I suppose the only way to know is to try it as already said.. I may just buy the extenders and hope for the best; if all else fails, at least the computers will be centralised. I can't see any reason for students to unplug the scanner though (not like a computer where they don't like "being monitored" - the scanner isn't any threat to them) I suppose the same problem could arise in event of a power cut, would the scanners know which VM to go back to, or even if the host PC is rebooted manually?
Originally Posted by Arthur
I read on the Canoscan guide that there seems to be a dropdown where you can select which scanner you want to configure. The obvious reason for this seems to be because you can choose separate config for each scanner; either that or so the program knows not to configure any other non-canon scanner device that may also be attached. Even if I get round that problem, I fear I may still have a driver limitation issue to deal with (this is in the non-VM scenerio).
That's the thing - funds do not allow at all, hence why i'd be looking at the "value" (cheapest) USB extender I can find, simply because anything that costs anymore is outside of our financial reach. This is also the reason why we adopted this setup in the first place as it meant we could use existing hardware at no extra cost to achieve essentially the same setup as one which is achieved using an actual network scanner. Plus, there are only 3 buttons on this setup, and nothing that can become "unconfigured" or messed with
Originally Posted by MatthewL
10th February 2010, 09:03 AM #18
Don't think unplugging will be a problem - that only seems to occur if you plug a device into a different USB socket. Given that pupils will only be able to get at the scanner end, the reconnect should be fine.
18th February 2010, 12:44 PM #19
Right, 1 week later I have the extenders. I move the host computer into our room and plug the extenders in as necessary, so I have scanner>usb cable>usb extender>ethernet link to our room>usb extender (reciever)>host computer.
All seems to look well - scanner picks up at host computer and asks to reinstall drivers. Scanner seems fine - is detected in device manager and a nice icon appears in "My Computer". If I unplug any cable this link, the scanner disappears (as expected) and reappears when I rejoin the link (again, as you would expect).
Unfortunately, computer seems to think scanner isn't connected when I try to scan something (front buttons or windows interface). This is odd as it picks it up fine and I reinstalled it fine, and the tests I did above obviously prove the computer knows it is there.
So, unless I can get this USB extender to work, it seems the computers will have to stay put! From scanner to PC, the entire length is about 15-20m (including USB and patch cables); much less than the quoted 50m for these devices.
18th February 2010, 12:50 PM #20
Not wishing to be a stuck record but its the voltage drop - theres enough to power the basic im a scanner electronic but not enough for the please scan electronics.
18th February 2010, 12:55 PM #21
My suggestions would be to try hooking up a powered USB device to one of the extenders like a printer and see if that talks. If it does it is the voltage drop and should be solvable by hooking up a powered USB hub to the scanner end of the extender then plugging the scanner into that.
I'd also try a different, more simple bit of hardware such as a usb stick to see it that interfaces correctly.
I'd also try on another of the extender links as it could be a faulty extender box or cat5e install as there can be deviation in the lengths of copper in a cable run that could be causing issues to.
Last edited by SYNACK; 18th February 2010 at 12:58 PM.
18th February 2010, 04:15 PM #22
Originally Posted by jamesreedersmith
I'll try and find one and give it a try (I haven't any to hand at the moment, quite frustratingly). It says scanner disconnected when it isn't even trying to scan anything though (when you load the config, it checks for the presence of the scanner, which it then says it can't find it, even though it still happily shows in My Computer and device manager).
Originally Posted by SYNACK
How much of a voltage drop are we talking about over the distance? Would the same be true if I just tested over a length of a couple of metres too?
Plugged in a USB pen drive where the scanner was plugged in, and this worked fine (could browse through files and open them up without issue). I guess this proves the extenders are working ok and the link hasn't got any breaks in it.
Originally Posted by SYNACK
18th February 2010, 04:31 PM #23
No the drop is proportional to the cable length so 2m would not be a valid test, does sound like a powered USB hub will solve it though which is good news.
Originally Posted by dgsmith
It could be worth plugging the scanner in directly via USB to its assigned port on the host machine to make sure it is not a software issue.
Last edited by SYNACK; 18th February 2010 at 05:35 PM.
18th February 2010, 06:04 PM #24
Not that's it's as helpful now that you've already bought extenders, but I have a netgear print server that can take a scanner too. You 'capture' the scanner in the software on a workstation, do your scanning and then release it again. Might be worth looking into.
19th March 2010, 09:08 AM #25
Well a month later we eventually managed to get USB hubs with power. Took us 3 weeks from BT Business as they kept shipping ones without power (labelling error) but got them in the end.
All works fine! It does seem like it was a power issue and now that is sorted, and fairly cheap as well (extenders £10 each, hubs /w power £4 each).
Just got to figure out if I go virtual or SANE driver now. The host machines are fairly old (Celeron 2.4 on Northwood core) so I don't know if running virtual machines is doable on them! Still, I think the major hurdle is over.
By cookie_monster in forum General Chat
Last Post: 2nd February 2010, 08:54 PM
By Little-Miss in forum Hardware
Last Post: 11th February 2009, 03:44 PM
By Scruff in forum Hardware
Last Post: 4th June 2007, 06:12 PM
By roymorden in forum Wireless Networks
Last Post: 30th June 2006, 09:03 PM
By russdev in forum Windows
Last Post: 24th August 2005, 07:38 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)