Can someone suggest a decent 1GB switch for use with 2 x SUN servers and 2 x 7110s. Each server has 4 nics and each 7110 has 2 so thats at least 12 ports need so Im learning towards a 24 port switch in case we add more hosts later. Would prefer HP but open to suggestions. Does the backplane speed need to be massivly fast?
Oooh, PC World Business have them for £650
You can also take a look at 3com 4800G, 5500G or 4500G series
@ - Geoff, do you have Flow control and Jumbo frames on at the same time on the HP's?
We're looking at HP Procurve 2910al switches for our SAN setupm, anyone using/looking at them?
How about a Cisco Catalyst 3560G-24TS
£2273.68 inc VAT at uk.insight.com
for something as critical as a SAN Switch, Cisco support is far better!
I know that Cisco is held in high esteem but HP switches are used in loads of data centers around the world. I've read articles with data center admins that say they have never had a HP switch fail on them. I've also never had a single issus with a HP switch.
How bad can they be?
How much do fiber modules cost for a Cisco are they more than HP as well we need four of them as well?
I've yet to see a major DC use anything but Cisco, unless it's Extreme Networks, Juniper, Brocade. With that said I have seen HP at the edge (where a Cisco 3000\2000 series would normally be) in some less "ISP" grade "DCs"
I've heard Cambs LEA say they had a number of issues with Cisco kit and they had trouble RMA it, thus why that have HP.
I don't think its so much the reliability issue
more the quality of support when it does go wrong!
however fiber modules should be priced similarly
Cisco - Transceiver module - SFP - Gigabit EN - 1000Base-SX - 850 nm - £239.28 inc VAT
I just looked on cisco site and i think the 4900 series is really the perfect match for a san switch however with the price tag to match of 4k! http://uk.insight.com/apps/productpr...6x%3D0%26y%3D0
I think for general LAN side there is no one right manufacture, all depends on what you want to do. If you are looking to a cisco voip system it makes sense to buy a cisco network.
Last edited by jam3s; 8th May 2009 at 07:57 PM.
In what way?Cisco support is far better!
Last edited by DMcCoy; 8th May 2009 at 10:05 PM. Reason: typo
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)