Hardware Thread, Rough costs to Implement SAN in Technical; Originally Posted by glennda
Read my post re Nimble - you get SSD performance from Sata drives.
A quick look ...
16th May 2013, 02:12 PM #31
A quick look at their website suggests you get ssd performance from the ssd's their chassis contains. Conceptually similar to Microsoft ReadyBoost, and Apple's Fusion.
Originally Posted by glennda
It'd be interesting to see what it could manage with on a busy fileserver volume where access is very random, fragmentation is potentially high and Shadow Copies management might triple the IOPs.
16th May 2013, 02:21 PM #32
They use the SSD's in a different way though, nothing is actually stored on the SSD's they are purely a cache for the HDD. It caches hot data and prempts reads and loads those into the cache incase.
Originally Posted by psydii
You will never get a fragmented disk with the way data is written to the disks as it has a constant sweeping process to clean itself up.
There is some very good videos on how CASL works on youtube and they are deffo worth a read. The bottleneck on these devices is the Intel Quad (Or Hex) core CPU as everything is driven from these.
16th May 2013, 02:31 PM #33
From the quick bits I've looked at, it seems that CASL is similar to ZFS in terms of ZFS having SLOG (not caching but speeds up sync writes... big explanation required) and L2ARC (SSD caching of most frequently used data) - I wonder if CASL has the equivalent of ARC as well (RAM caching of most recently used data)? And if the write caching buffers non-sync io (which I believe is what SMB/CIFS is)?
It may also be worth a look at Nexenta - Software Defined Storage, have a few resellers in the UK - it's what I based our self build on - we didn't go with Nexenta as there weren't any Xeon E5 certified platforms when we were looking to buy, and I didn't want to be on out of date tech.
16th May 2013, 02:38 PM #34
But the biggest different is that a nimble storage array will not slow down when its full - whereas a ZFS array will as its WAFL when the array gets "dirty", Nimble is always a sequential block layout
Originally Posted by Willott
16th May 2013, 03:44 PM #35
Potentially a moot point. vmdk's perform better when not thin provisioned, so if you are configuring for best performance the blocks are pre-allocated on the disk in advance, and contiguously.
Originally Posted by glennda
16th May 2013, 04:12 PM #36
Well this is where the controller is even cleverer and the VStorage intergration kicks in, Even if you Thick provision eager zero, the controller picks up that it is having multiple zero's written to a disk and just acknowledges the write back to the hypervisor, when infact it doesn't actually write anything to the array, this causes no performance issues as 99% of the time when using thin provision the reason it tends to perform worse is that is has to ensure it can write to the space before writing it. Nimble takes this away.
Originally Posted by psydii
Also if you are planning on thin provisioning SCSI Unmap (space reclamation) which was introduced in VSphere 5.0 is fully supported (one of the first big players to do so).
EDIT: the thing is with most of these features are they are designed for large enterprise, whereas 99.999999% of schools will never full utilize these features.
Last edited by glennda; 16th May 2013 at 04:17 PM.
17th May 2013, 12:31 PM #37
I wouldn't myself having had two of them the on-costs went through the roof with Oracle, support was very poor and not worth the large £K they were charging for support.
Originally Posted by seawolf
I would be looking at something from EMC if buying now yes the Oracle kit was more reasonably priced than EMC but in hindsight much more worth it.
17th May 2013, 01:18 PM #38
Possibly that is the case for support in the UK, I can't say. Not sure what you mean about the expensive on-costs? Other than some initial problems with firmware in the early days in 2009 (fixed soon thereafter) I've had good support and low on-costs for the Oracle kit (I have some 4170s and 4150s as well).
Originally Posted by john
You hear horror stories about all vendors, and I've heard some about all of the major vendors, including EMC, HP, Equalogic, Sun/Oracle, and others. I think the Oracle kit is very good, but HP works just fine, and so does IX Systems (FreeNAS) in my own experience and I've heard people rave about the roll your own SAM-SD solutions.
I always suggest asking for a loan/demo unit from the vendor solutions you shortlist as meeting the requirements to find out for yourself. I can get a piece of Oracle kit spun up in a heartbeat, a FreeNAS system just a touch longer, and the HP SAN takes me a fair bit longer (I find the UI unintuitive and confusing). Unless someone else will be configuring and supporting the SAN all of the time, It's always important to have something you understand and that isn't just a mysterious black box to you.
5th August 2013, 06:15 PM #39
- Rep Power
If anyone has any technical questions about Hybrid Storage platforms please feel free to post or DM me and we will do our best to answer them.
Hybrid platforms are certainly an exciting but often confusing emerging part of the storage offerings from traditional and some newer vendors.
5th August 2013, 11:04 PM #40
Our Nimble is being setup tomorrow so I will let everyone know how it fairs next to our equallogic which has been faultless by all accounts.
8th August 2013, 12:34 AM #41
Our Nimble cs220 was setup yesterday, Ezat from Nimble did a sterling job of going through all the features and I can confirm that it lives up to the hype in terms of performance and easy of use. It took me a couple of hours to setup the volumes, migrate a couple of VMs and test and as of today I have all bar one VM running off Nimble storage. The poor old equallogic is looking a little antiquated by comparison.
8th August 2013, 01:26 AM #42
Just my 2p but RE: the talk of enterprise SSDs on the last page, you don't necessarily need enterprise SSDs. Consumer ones will work just as well for most purposes we throw at them, stick them in a RAID6 and you're good to go. This has been rigorously tested by a local consultancy company who previously showed me some statistics over a years use (must be 2 years now), enterprise SSDs obviously have a place in the market, but I don't really see schools as one of them...
I've been quite happily using consumer SSDs in two SANs hosting VMs for the past year and a bit now, had one drive fail early in its life (which you often get with conventional disks too - they die early or they die late) apart from that things have been running wonderfully. I still have an array of conventional HDDs for the stuff that does crazy writes, but for areas where reads are more prominent the SSDs do a good job.
The key to it really is tiered storage. .... of course I'm talking purely VM hosting here, not backup or file data etc.
Yes enterprise drives are faster, more reliable and designed for a purpose, but the cost doesn't necessarily equal the value when you consider that consumer equipment can still give us massively increased performance over conventional drives but at a fraction of the cost and still work within the boundaries we as school set them. For serving up say 10 VMs, all doing tasks that aren't massive on writes, but would be aided by nice fast read speeds, consumer SSDs will tick that box. Just to state that I'm not saying it's wrong to buy enterprise ones, but that i wanted to make it clear that it's not your only option.
Last edited by mrbios; 8th August 2013 at 01:47 AM.
8th August 2013, 01:50 PM #43
- Rep Power
Thanks for the kind words Tallwood_6.
Welcome to the next generation of easy to use general purpose perfomant storage!
Glad all went well.
8th August 2013, 02:15 PM #44
what did you get and how much did it cost if you dont mind me asking?
8th August 2013, 04:13 PM #45
By reggiep in forum Network and Classroom Management
Last Post: 17th August 2010, 04:51 PM
By albertwt in forum Thin Client and Virtual Machines
Last Post: 12th May 2010, 09:43 AM
By Sam_Brown in forum Virtual Learning Platforms
Last Post: 8th November 2009, 10:57 PM
By wagnerk in forum General Chat
Last Post: 7th July 2009, 01:07 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)