CHR1S (23rd March 2010)
Yeah, the chemical reaction needs a lot of energy put in to get it to go as it were, however, its possible, as DAF have achieved it at a sensible cost.
The only reason they don't have the SCR system on cars is:
Where to put the urea tank?
Will Joe Public pay the money to refill the urea tank?
Can it be refiled as a service operation - i.e refill at each service? (service interval of 15 - 20k miles on a Citroen petrol these days, so I'm informed)
Can enough be stored on the car to get it from one service to the next?
everyone knows that it will help if we have a SCR system, the problem as always is will we pay for it and is it a long term solution?
I have an RX8, best not talk about fuel economy then I thinks
I had an RX-8 for a while.
They're great fun but as ZH says 23mpg is a little low!!
Beat me to it ahuxham! lol
For around £700-800 you can get the DPF removed. If you work out how much extra fuel you use to clear the DPF over the time you intend to own the car it may pay for itself.
On some cars - the removal of the DPF actually improves performance and mpg. The DPF is not a legal requirement.
I've got a 58 Mondeo 2.0 TDCi and how that works is an element in the DPF - if the exhaust gets hot enough it sorts itself out, if it gets to 500 miles without it doing it, at the 500 mile point, the element kicks in and causes regeneration.
The problem with any DPF regeneration process is it takes time, I am told 10-20 minutes depending upon engine speed; if the ECU decides it's time for a regeneration 30 seconds before you arrive at your destination it will fail. If your next few journeys after that are short trips with the system never getting enough time to clear the filter you can be easily caught out as the ECU counts down to turning on limp-home mode & then you are into dealer regeneration, I have seen sums of up to £200 mentioned for the dealer to regenerate the filter & many treat it as driver error & refuse to perform regeneration under warranty without a fight.
It looks like I cannot risk using 6th gear on my car for my normal commute anymore. Ridiculous!
Someone should take Nissan to task with the advertising standards authority over their 'urbanproof' Quashqui ads.... clearly not applicable to their 2.0 diesel versions
Last edited by broc; 24th March 2010 at 08:28 AM.
We're you made aware during sales, or did the manuals state the DPF function doesn't work as advised when using it for short trips? If not, there is clearly a case, and guaranteed, if spoken to the dealer/garage about it, they wont quibble about getting it fixed without cost
Revival of an old topic here this came up as a similar thread to the old cars one and funny enough this week I've been looking at a few cars mainly 170PD and CD TDI engines which all come with DPF's and researching into the cars I've found so many people complaining about DPF issues, mixed reports on the rumor of long driving makes a difference as the DPF re-gen could kick in after the long drive and stupid pricing from dealers to simply force charge. Near half of these reports ended up being false sensors sticking at a % and stopping the DPF cycle finishing.
It looks like more recently alot of garages offer DPF removal service, completely cutting out the internals of the DPF and removing it from the ECU, others offer a bypass pipe to replace the DPF section of the exhaust. Both don't affect MOT's and providing you don't have heavy remaps shouldn't cause smoking
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)