General Chat Thread, DSI Stolen from school - Who is responsible? in General; One of our Year 6 pupils stupidly brought his Nintendo DSI into school on Friday. He was staying with his ...
26th January 2010, 11:37 AM #1
DSI Stolen from school - Who is responsible?
One of our Year 6 pupils stupidly brought his Nintendo DSI into school on Friday. He was staying with his Dad the weekend and wanted to use it whilst he was there.
I dont know the ins and outs but it somehow got out and he got it confiscated by a supply teacher in the class at the time.
The supply teacher put it in a basket on her desk until the end of the day. Well, it seems it was left there over lunchtime which happened to be wet play that day so all the children would of been in that room with minimal supervision (dinner ladies are next to useless)
Anyway fastfoward to after lunch and the DSI has gone. The pupil is obviously devistated and i really feel sorry for him. He doesnt get much and his parents are not exactly role models, his older brothers are always in and out of prison.
So . . . who do you think would technically be responsinble for the DSI?
I personally think that school should replace it. i understand that it should of never been in school in the first place but as soon as the teacher confiscated it then I believe they took responsibility for its safe keeping and returning to the pupil..
I dont think that its being investigated by the school and they didnt even search the childrens bags at the end of the day on Friday so no doubt its long gone by now.
IDG Tech News
26th January 2010, 11:41 AM #2
I'd also expect the school to replace it, though legally I'm not sure who would be liable...
26th January 2010, 11:48 AM #3
It would be down to the school, surely the supply teacher will conform when they placed it.
The class should also be taught a lesson and sat down and someone should confess. Either that and/or a letter home.
26th January 2010, 11:52 AM #4
I would have thought that it would be down to the school, or the very least the teacher. Once she has taken it(even if it shouldn't be in school) then she takes responsibility and shouldn't have left it unsecured. If it was mine that was stolen, I would expect to have it replaced.
26th January 2010, 11:54 AM #5
Not sure who should replace it, but the supply teacher should be given a lesson in common sense regarding not leaving valuables unsecured.
26th January 2010, 12:07 PM #6
I remember reading about this not so long ago, a teacher confisgated a phone and it got stolen. By taking the phone the teacher is taking responsibility for the item. If it is lost, damaged or stolen whilst in this persons (the teachers) care. It is up to the person (the teacher) to show they took care of the item i.e log book to say locked in safe etc etc... if they cannot prove they have taken care of the item it is that persons or the organistation of which they represent to replace the item for the individual.
Please dont quote me though as I cant remember where saw it. Think it was on the tv dont get screwed? maybe? :P
hope it helps anyway
26th January 2010, 12:19 PM #7
In my view, the school is negligent. The supply teacher took on responsibility for it when s/he took on possession through confiscating it. This kind of thing is precisely why we don't allow student laptops in school, even in sixth form.
26th January 2010, 12:21 PM #8
Surely at primary school age parents would notice their kids coming home with a DSI, maybe a letter out would inform them that it was stolen and not leant to their kid?
Is the school in a rough area?
26th January 2010, 12:22 PM #9
Common sense would dictate the school is liable (whether or not the school persues the Supply Teacher is a different matter). Even though the kid shouldn't have had the DS in school the teacher assumed responsibility when they confiscated it.
If it had just been in the kids bag/possession and gone missing then tough, by all means search the other students etc but it's not a school issue.
If it's only occasionally stuff gets confiscated maybe a central holding area (safe at front of school) and a receipt/ticket system could work?
26th January 2010, 12:26 PM #10
Think your right, but the example was when the personal belonging was damaged? Dont see any difference to if it was stolen. Respsonsibility still lies with the business who took respsonsiblity of your personal item and it wasn't looked after appropriately it is up to them to replace it or pay for the item to be fixed. So I think it falls on the school to replace, whether they would do anything to the teacher for being negligent(ie pay) is a different matter.
Originally Posted by neon
26th January 2010, 12:27 PM #11
Really depends on the schools policy on students bringing electronics into the school. But I would expect the supply teacher to at least compensate half for leaving it insecure.
26th January 2010, 12:31 PM #12
Not sure how you come up with half... is three fifths reasonable? five eighths? The supply teacher hasn't lost a bit of it, they've lost the whole thing.
Originally Posted by p858snake
26th January 2010, 12:38 PM #13
Something similar happened to me when my daughter's watch was taken for safe-keeping by a teacher and never seen again. I argued that they were responsible but they wouldnt have it and just stonewalled me until I gave up in the end
26th January 2010, 12:55 PM #14
It's the school's responsibility. It was confiscated by the school (which the teacher is acting on behalf of) and therefore it's up to the school to ensure that it's safe.
A DSi has an rrp of £150, so it's not a trivial issue.
26th January 2010, 12:55 PM #15
Yeh, were not in the nicest of areas. Half our parents are being monitored by social services for something or another. Half the parents wouldnt bat an eyelid if their child came home with someone else's DSI.
Originally Posted by Dom_
I totally agree, if it would have gone from out of his bag then tough but seeing as the supply teacher took it off him I really think the school should replace it.
Originally Posted by TwoZeroAlpha
I dont think anything is being done, neither parent have kicked up a fuss but it may be that they dont know yet?
But I really feel sorry for this child. He relly hasnt had much of a chance in life so far. Some of the stories staff have heard from him are awfull.
There was talk of the staff doing a collection and replacing it for him. I hope it happens
By Curt_LFC in forum Hardware
Last Post: 28th September 2009, 02:28 PM
By rush_tech in forum General Chat
Last Post: 17th September 2009, 04:38 PM
By silver in forum General Chat
Last Post: 25th March 2009, 03:55 PM
By beeswax in forum ICT KS3 SATS Tests
Last Post: 25th April 2006, 08:29 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)