General Chat Thread, Censorship on Edugeek !!! in General; Why was this thread closed and free and open speech stopped by Diello... ?
what right has he to decide ...
14th October 2008, 04:42 PM #1
Censorship on Edugeek !!!
Why was this thread closed and free and open speech stopped by Diello... ?
what right has he to decide that that's it I'm closing this thread because I want to or because he doesn't like the topic.. this smacks of censorship?
One rule for one....
if i just want a site where I get only technical advice I wopuld join some bland Microsoft Forum
This place is starting to blow
IDG Tech News
14th October 2008, 04:44 PM #2
WUH WUH !! Thats the sound of Edugeek Police....Wuh Wuh.....
14th October 2008, 04:48 PM #3
mattx. You are the cause of many drink-splurting issues involving IT support staff and computer equipment Edugeek says I can't give you any more rep yet, but it's the thought that counts :P
14th October 2008, 04:52 PM #4
Hmm... lets see shall we Grommit?
Originally Posted by Grommit
1 - Deliberately using a 4-letter expletive in a post after Dos_Box's precise announcement not to?
2 - Deliberately goading the staff by asking to get an infraction for it?
3 - Replying to witch with a reference to growing up, maturity and staff being "hall monitors".
A question was asked regarding "one rule for one", it was answered, first by staff, and then by the site owner in an announcement. Other members had accepted that and moved on, but you just had to try to stir it up again in the thread, ignore what the Admins had decided, and basically try to get yourself banned with "suicide by cop".
You seem to be under this strange illusion that EduGeek is a democracy - it's not, if the owner tells you to do something, it's a pretty good guess it didn't come with an "if you want" attached to the end.
Not to mention it was the opinion of not just me to close the thread...
Last edited by Diello; 14th October 2008 at 04:55 PM.
14th October 2008, 04:54 PM #5
How did I know a thread with this title and with these folks was immediately going to appear..
This is not a democracy, it is not collective of the common people, it is privately owned, run and operated by an individual with a series of volunteers handling much of the day to day tasks.
If you don't like it, go create your own nirvana... and good luck.
14th October 2008, 04:55 PM #6
Arrrrrr Shucks..... made me go all red........ brother.
Originally Posted by webman
Its a mad world out there, if you can't have a bit of fun.........
14th October 2008, 05:10 PM #7
I always find it strange for people to hang in around in a place they so clearly despise.
Personal opinion: these kind of follow up threads should be locked before the whole thing starts up again
14th October 2008, 09:52 PM #8
..it's forum for school IT techs!!!
Originally Posted by contink
Why complain that the site acts like a site for school IT Techs?!?!
That to me seems to be what you are saying Grommit? This isn't a platform for free speech or a test of moral decency. We have professional standards and we bring those here with us. We have to if we want to use this site in our jobs. Like Diello suggests, if you want more you need to be in another place. Shame I know, as it's here you find like mind souls with a shared interest. Maybe we should have a no holds barred secret sister site.
I forget that sometimes this site does need to be school clean. Like with my picture on the Credit Crunch jokes thread. To me, lots of stuff flies over my decency radar, and it appears I went too far with that one. I was actually directly quoting Richard Dawkins in a post on his own forums. Possibly not a good moral thermometer
Hightower complained that I didn't get the sametreatment as others, whilst ignoring what we all know to be the process, of pressing thereport button. In my opinion, he only did this to stir up trouble, because he couldn't accept his own wrong doing. Nothing more.
14th October 2008, 09:57 PM #9
I do think this site is going down hill fast its just not as fun as when i first joined, its becoming to serious.
14th October 2008, 10:12 PM #10
only because a few people want to play up and take it too far. funs still there to be had.
Originally Posted by Quackers
14th October 2008, 10:23 PM #11
I'm not sure I agree its less fun, but its certainly becoming more professional, and is that necessarily such a bad thing?
Originally Posted by Quackers
I don't think so but I guess it depends on your reasons for coming here. I think its about bringing professionals with a shared (and probably fairly unique in terms of workplace) experience to help each other out, share ideas and generally improve our IT service across our schools. If that means we have to act professionally then so be it. I would rather that than some of the nonsense going on lately.
I think that certain recent events show that as the site becomes more popular, it will be read more "outsiders" and this is going to restrict the things we say anyway. Do we really want to portray our profession the way some threads have? (Not saying I am blameless here, if Iook back I am sure there are some posts I have made that I probably wouldn't make again)
To be honest I think, if any, Edugeek is getting better not worse.
(btw I am not saying that I am right, just that this is my way of thinking)
14th October 2008, 10:31 PM #12
I was waiting for this sort of topic to appear. It appears to be the same people time and time again complaining of censorship. I see it like this - this site is privately owned. It isn't a collective. It isn't a democracy.
Why must the site be a free for all of poor behaviour? I know I wouldn't continue to come here if it were - justifying its use to my boss would become a lot harder! This site is used by a significant number of people for solving problems and for professional development. Sure, have some fun - clean fun. Sure have a rant, but without it being expletive filled. Why do you need those things?
I know this will sound like an old stereotyped american (you know, 'if you don't like it, yuh can get out')- but if you don't like the way the site is ran, or the way it is going, you are always free to not use it.
14th October 2008, 10:50 PM #13
Aw heck.. it's a forum that's going through growing pains...
When places like this are small and new then folks are more likely to get along and the rules are fairly relaxed because the spirit of the community holds sway. But it gets popular and grows bigger, folks are less likely to know each other and every community has it's troll who likes the attention of notoriety. Then it gets to a critical point where some folks feel the old feel has gone, which it has and stricter structures and rules have to take sway or the whole thing hits critical mass and implodes.
This is as true of this place as any other and if anything the fact that it has a much greater professional remit makes it even more inescapable that it's going to be less "fun" and more "serious".
... and does anyone doubt that there are LEA, Managers, Heads, etc... all looking at this place with a much more jaundiced eye and wondering if it's actually worth blocking. You can already see more than a few that have suffered from that and you can bet it won't stop there.
Self fulfilling prophecy anyone?
14th October 2008, 10:54 PM #14
Can I just say I've never kissed the editor of the Radio Times.....
14th October 2008, 10:57 PM #15
The most heated we use to get was a good old Vanilla vs RM debate, now some things get extreamly heated and not in a light hearted way.
FFS! Forum posts seem to take up 80% of the recent threads screen.
With the exception of the Sophos incident i cannot remember things getting censored before, and rules did not seem to pop up like they have this time.
Its still a handy site, even if i do pull my hair when using the sites wiki, infact i was swearing at it last week trying to find what i wanted on it.
I'd get rid of the FFS forum anyway, venting rage of a forum may not be the best place, its like recording yourself smashing somthing up, it might get seen.
By Mr_M_Cox in forum Network and Classroom Management
Last Post: 19th November 2007, 10:55 AM
By Dos_Box in forum General Chat
Last Post: 18th May 2007, 07:59 PM
By drjturner in forum General Chat
Last Post: 21st December 2006, 01:23 PM
By mrforgetful in forum Jokes/Interweb Things
Last Post: 27th November 2006, 09:42 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)