Complaints were heard: BBC News - Olympic snowboarding commentary draws complaints
Luge and skeleton are my faves.
I suppose because its like the grown up version of sledging which I loved as a child, and still do. Anyone remember John Noaks going down the cresta run for Blue Peter?
When is it going to snow this year so I can get 'lighning' out of the garage and drag my girls down to the park?
Ok, I agree with some of the comments being out of place, such as the 'face that makes bread rise', but aside from that I thought having someone in the booth who knew about riding was a fresh position. So often you get people who don't know the basics commentating and it makes it very stale and clinical.
It was great to have enthusiasm put into the commentary, but it needed to be reigned in in places.
Wow you guys all have gigantic sticks up your posteriors about this snowboarding commentary. I thought it was the best commentary we've had out of any of the events - the commentators obviously were extremely knowledgable about the sport AND incredibly enthusiastic about it, something which I think has been missing from a lot of the commentary on the other events. Did you seriously put a complaint into the BBC because somebody showed that they were an actual person whilst talking about a sporting event?
Out of interest, how many of you wrote letters about the appalling violations of human rights going on in russia?
Yeah, there's being knowledgeable and enthusiastic then there's blatant bias swirled in with incredibly pathetic comments made.
Personally I found the BBC commentary very good. It reflected the whole spirit of the event and the enthusiasm shown by Amiee Fuller in support of her team mate was very infectious and captured how so many of us felt when watching it.
For far too long we have suffered that stiff upper lip jolly well done half hearted support from our national broadcaster and this made a welcome and refreshing change. Far from making me feel old (I'm 55) and out of touch, I found the enthusiasm very refreshing.
I've watched a lot of this sort of sports, downhil mountainbiking, freestyle skiing, slopestyle and X games, Redbull promoted sports etc, and this is just how it's done. I saw nothing wrong with it as commentary for what it was, it is obviously less, how shall we say, 'Classy' than that for ice dance, but its a different audience most of the time.
It might have been an idea for the producers to get everyone on the commentary team to watch some previous commentary for say, superG and tell them 'Thats the level we expect'.
I'm really in it for the sliding... I've always watched all of the Bobsleigh, Skeleton and Luge, and I watch the preceeding world champs on eurosport before hand as well.
The men's moguls finals last night were seriously good, the Canadian that won it was incredible!
I am currently watching the final of the women's ski slopestyle and the commentary is superb - enthusiastic, informative and understandable. Just how it should be done
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)