General Chat Thread, Meh F1. in General; 4 world championships. A huge array of media folks reporting Vettel is "one of the greats".
NO. Tell me why? ...
27th October 2013, 03:34 PM #1
4 world championships. A huge array of media folks reporting Vettel is "one of the greats".
NO. Tell me why? They can't. Every positive thing they have to say about Vettel in supposed support of their claims should be geared towards the team he drives for.
There is no way this guy can be compared, like they are doing often, to the likes of Fangio or Schumacher. He isn't even in the same league as Alonso or Hamilton. Yet the latter is rarely mentioned these days despite what he's doing in a new team. Alonso, Hamilton and Raikkonen are all racers, a term you can't fairly put next to Vettel's name. Without team orders the guy is in trouble when it comes to getting past similar performing cars.
The car itself is yet again a masterpiece. Red Bull have yet again harnessed another loophole in engine mapping (ECU this, ECU that...) that is effectively giving them something akin to traction control. They're very good at hiding their little rule-benders and interpreting them in a way that suits them, on top of the fact they have an absolute genius designer. Hopefully next year brings something new, because this year the only thing worth watching are some midfield battles and Hamilton pulling some great performances and some stonking speeds from the Merc. Lets hope the new engines can throw a permanent curveball in Red Bull's direction, because I for one would like to see a Driver's World Championship go to the most deserving Driver, and the Constructors World Championship going to the most deserving constructor. Currently that isn't the case.
27th October 2013, 03:43 PM #2
People said the same when Schumaker just kept winning with Ferrari, so not really fair.
Whilst I think he is arrogant, he is what he is, and that is a winner. Given time it will sort it self out and the better drivers will come back and shine again.
27th October 2013, 03:43 PM #3
27th October 2013, 05:06 PM #4
Schumacher was able to drag the less than capable Ferrari of 96 and 97 up to way beyond it's actual ability. The same has been proven of many drivers including Hamilton and Alonso. Granted Schumacher cheated his way to a world championship and the less said about Ferrari the better, but RB are a level beyond. Schumacher was still a proven excellent driver. The same couldn't be said for Vettel who has yet to prove himself on his own. He's proven to be very shakable under pressure and rather childish when he doesn't get his own way, and that doesn't work too well to the teams advantage!
27th October 2013, 08:06 PM #5
- Rep Power
He is a great driver, which get's lost behind such a great car. He's had amazing success prior to F1. He has Toro Rosso's only race victory. He also won 18 of 20 races in Formula BMW in 2003 or 2004.
He hasn't been racing zombies in go karts his whole career, he's achieved an amazing feat. I'll wait till the end of his career to call him a great though.
Thanks to madurham from:
speckytecky (27th October 2013)
27th October 2013, 09:46 PM #6
As much as i hate vettel only due to the cockyness and red bull, i cannot stand horner, i think the fia need to look at relaxing some of the rules a little bit. Why cant someone celebrate by doing doughnuts on the track. Aparently they sent out 2 fia members to check the car and make sure it wasnt tampered with after vettel got out the car. I think if the fia took a leaf out of motogp's, f1 might be a bit more enjoyable to watch. Everything seems so structured and political.
As for red bull winning the drivers and constructors again, i think the only person you need to take out the team is newey. Newey was at Williams when they were winning and im sure he was at mclaren when they were winning too. It seems to me, vettel controls the team and if he says jump horner says how high. I want to see mark win a race this year. I cant help but think that mark keeps getting duff parts.
I hope next season will be better with the new engines and weight limits which i think they need the revisit, f1 will soon be a sport where drives have to be shorter than 6ft and weigh less than 70kg.
Last edited by timbo343; 27th October 2013 at 09:54 PM.
28th October 2013, 10:59 AM #7
Stick Lewis in that Red Bull and I bet he would find another .5 of a second a lap. That is the thing with Lewis - he will find that in ANY car you stick him in.
The season before he joined Red Bull I think he had one or two podiums ? Can't remember off hand but it was nothing that special. Average driver but amazing car. Next year will sort out the men from the boys.
28th October 2013, 11:39 AM #8
Seems to be the big discussion on every site, several articles etc etc
I think Vettel is a great, if he isn't then Webber is a bigger waste of space? he is blowing him away with ease and everything seems to be going Vettels way. Even with being on different tyres or no kers still manages it.
Of course there is always going to be doubters till he has a proven team mate like Alonso and Lewis. It's going to be an interesting year for Kimi though in 2014
There is no doubting though that the RBR and the team is just superb, would have been nice to see Webbers car have more reliability though.
28th October 2013, 11:53 AM #9
Webber gets screwed by team orders and all focus on Vettel. A test on their cars last season shown that Webbers car had less torque and BHP by around 2%, because the adjustments made to Vettels car were not done on Webbers. 2% might not sound like much but it is enough to lose the competitive edge. This was on the 3rd of 4th engine they were testing.
28th October 2013, 11:56 AM #10
Originally Posted by nephilim
28th October 2013, 11:57 AM #11
We all know Webber doesn't have the same car as Vettel, certainly when it comes to the latest rule-bending gadgets and the traction-aiding engine mappings that can't possibly exist. We know he's not an excellent driver, not up there with the rest of them but Vettel isn't up there with Alonso/Hamilton yet.
28th October 2013, 12:03 PM #12
Read in the F1 magazine at my stepdads house.
28th October 2013, 12:33 PM #13
Ha! I don't much like Vettel, but mediocre drivers just don't win 4 titles. It also is very much a team sport of which the actual race is a relatively small (but hugely important) part. There are hundreds of man years behind a car going into a season and many man years behind each iteration of the car. There is no doubt that RBR focus that development effort more on Vettel, building a car that suits him even where that is at the expense of the other driver. That doesn't lessen Vettel's achievement.
Originally Posted by mthomas08
(and surely in these days of F1 becoming ever duller, the driver just staying awake is an achievement).
Last edited by pcstru; 28th October 2013 at 12:34 PM.
28th October 2013, 01:23 PM #14
- Rep Power
Vettel is a good driver, I will give him that, but he is no way great. When you consider that his car has different driving aids and devices on it that even his team mate doesn't have, it puts it into perspective that he might not be as good as it appears.
There is talk that Vettel has a traction system on his car but Webber doesn't because of his weight, this was noticed at Singapore by Gian Carlo Minardi, who saw that Vettel was able to get on the power earlier than anyone else and that his engine was grinding like none of the other Renault engines, now this would pose a huge advantage over the course of a lap let alone a race or even the season.
Another thing with Red Bull is that the team isn't run by the supposed team boss Adrian Horner, it is run by Vettel and Helmut Marko as much as people like to disagree with that when you look at the decisions made and punishments to drivers after incidents, Malaysia, they either favor Vettel or punish Webber.
Unless there is equal treatment between the two Red Bull drivers, or even the FIA to close some of these loopholes within the regulations, I don't think you can call Vettel great as his machinery is on a different level to anyone else.
In F1 I believe they need to bring in some form of control parts like they have within touring cars, it increases race excitement and also helps to bring costs down. F1 needs to look at bringing its costs down because otherwise drivers won't want to compete unless they are in a top car and sponsors won't be able to afford to back the top two or three teams.
BTW David Ward for FIA President!
28th October 2013, 01:36 PM #15
How is that not the case? You said yourself "the car is a masterpiece" and "they have an absolute genius designer", they have superb reliability (in Vettel's case at least!); what other considerations should go into the constructors championship?
Originally Posted by synaesthesia
I do think the RBR has been far and away the best car and has perhaps given Vettel the appearance of a dominance he doesn't necessarily have, but he is inarguably a good driver. You don't get consistent laps, consistent pole positions and consistent victories by accident. The man is a machine - a very-dull-to-watch-machine, but he executes his drive flawlessly 98% of the time. Sometimes he acts like a pillock (multi 2 1 and all that) but he's 26, young, arrogant and competitive - in other words, a racing driver.
His race yesterday shows he's capable - after pitting on lap 2 he shot back up the rankings, overtaking beyond even the expectations of his team judging by the radio messages. Again, the car is undoubtedly an advantage, and it uses some design tricks others can't fathom or match - but Vettel is the driver who knows how to work that to his advantage, how to drive that RBR round corners in the way that suits its aerodynamics, how to play the throttle to vent the exhaust to create the downforce to give him the grip out of the corner. If there was traction control going on, don't you think the Ferrari International Association would be all over RBR? Or are we pretending the FIA are in the control of Red Bull now that they're dominant?
(although I do think the FIA/Ferrari were a bit cosy back in the day, to be fair.)
Webber has had rotten luck and undoubtedly played second fiddle to Helmut's favourite, but even when his luck holds he's been competitive with the other top teams, not dominant like Vettel - and Webber is a superb driver in and of himself.
It's been a boring second half of the season watching Vettel dominate, and I've only been watching for the battles around 2-6th that have been so entertaining (I think the field of talent on track at the moment is amazing - Alonso, Hamilton, Raikonnen, Button, even Grosjean at the moment) and I am very much looking forward to the rules changes shaking it up. But pretending that Vettel isn't a good driver is nonsense. An arrogant prat, perhaps, a lucky son-of-a to be in the RBR, yes; but still a good driver.
By cooper in forum Other Stuff
Last Post: 4th November 2008, 10:34 AM
By ahuxham in forum Office Software
Last Post: 13th May 2008, 01:12 PM
By russdev in forum General Chat
Last Post: 25th March 2008, 07:35 PM
By ZeroHour in forum Educational Software
Last Post: 20th August 2007, 12:06 PM
By russdev in forum General Chat
Last Post: 25th August 2006, 10:32 PM
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)