Last edited by LeMarchand; 30th January 2010 at 10:13 AM. Reason: Typo
Good points contik + Si.
As another Primary Tech the 4 school I currently support are all W2K3 + XP and everything works how it should and works well. As wonderful as W7 there is nothing I can't currently do with my setups that would warrant a change to W7. It's not the huge change that W2K + XP was over NT4 + W98.
Cost is a huge consideration. The money that it would cost to upgrade to W2K8 + W7 would be in the thousands. This money could be spent on better wireless infrastructure, equipment for pupils and staff such as visualisers, camera, data loggers, video cameras, digital microscopes, curriculum software, the list goes on. This will benefit Teaching and Learning far more than an OS upgrade.
Personally I plan to roll out W7 gradually as new kit comes with it installed. You can manage W7 clients with W2K3 in the same way you could Vista.
SimpleSi (30th January 2010)
I was just about to post my 'primary tech' views when I read SYSMAN_MK's he's said everything I was thinking!
Although, it's equally important in my mind to make sure we don't lag behind the senior schools too much for the sake of the pupils.
Money is an issue in primaries and in mine we're just about able to replace hardware to maintain a status quo.
On a similar note has anyone upgraded recently from office 2003 to 2007 and knows the cost per licence?
Our LA supply Office 2007 Pro for about £35.00 IIRC
Just about to replace a primary school's complete network with a Server 2008 R2/Windows 7 setup. I agree that if you've got a healthy XP/2003 system in place, there's not necessarily a rush to upgrade, but the school in question has an ICT suite they simply can't use, due to the 7-year-old PCs being next to useless, and their Windows 2000 server (which is of the same vintage) being on its last legs.
My view is this: if a school is due to replace kit, then there's no real reason not to go for Windows 7 (compatibility issues with old software aside).
No we have 2003 licences, at least for the pupil machines, the staff laptops are a different kettle of fish - I'll look into that! Good thinking
Also just looked at microsoft schools agreement, realised with our recent purchases we now have reached the min quantity required, unable to find a price though, is it expensive?
Last edited by chrbb; 30th January 2010 at 01:18 PM.
Compatibility is very often able to be sorted by the Application Compatibility Toolkit, you can set up a policy for the bit of software in question configureing all sorts of compatibility fixes not avalible via the basic run as XP mode and these settings can be pushed to the whole network. The primary issues with compatibility are usually antivirus programs and pc control software, as long as you have rights to the latest versions of these then most other issues can be solved with the above toolkit and a bit of fiddeling.
of course notMy view is this: if a school is due to replace kit, then there's no real reason not to go for Windows 7 (compatibility issues with old software aside).
And it would be nice to know which old software doesn't work.
I'd suspsect that all Foundation/KS1 DK/Sherston/Oxford titles could be trouble for starters (but then again its tricky to get some of them working on XP )
As an experiment, it would be nice for an expert (e.g not me to try just getting one (say year 2) class onto Win7 - install it on teachers laptop and smartboard connected computer and the 2 class PCs (or a couple of the schools laptop trolley machines) and see what happens.
I know the Abacus Maths Framework doesn't work on Vista so that'd be a good one to see if works under Win7s vaulted XP mode
PS Ignoring W2k8+Win7 clients arrangement (cause I imagine there's all sort of goodies in that arrangement for you domain control freaks ) is there anything in Win7 itself you'd consider as being really good.
Ignoring esoteric things like "security" and "stability"
I mean - whats really wrong with WfWg3.11?
One of the primaries i cove is going to windows 7. I am going to Windows Server 2008 R2 with Windows 7 Enterprise at easter. The staff know and have had access to a couple of test machines since September. Had a couple of worried looks, but they will have to get used to it and have had plenty of time to look at the software during ppa time etc.
Much better self repair ability (system files, reg etc)
Way better over VPN/remote links due to a much faster network stack
More managability via GP even if you only have a Windows 2000 server as DC
Better power managment, suspend for powersave etc.
Easier install with support for non cretatious era hardware ie SATA drives
Automated multipass defragmentation
Fully integrated .net 3.5 framework and windows installer modules makeing .net stuff run faster and stuff install faster. This is important when pushing managed MSIs.
Automated presentation mode that detects projectors when attached and offers a wizard to help
Built in codecs for lots of different formats avoiding the need for DVD software or Quicktime/xvid etc.
Is just the stuff off the top of my head that has made a difference here (most applied to Vista too).
I remember 3.11, it was fine for playing solitare on as I reacall and even had a 32bit mode that could be installed for full 32bit freecell
doesn't apply to non-domain machines - all files just stay on laptopsWay better offline files for teacher laptops
Is it possible to quantify such a thing or is this just a feeling/marketing feature - no way to prove wither way I suspectMuch better self repair ability (system files, reg etc)
Only if you've got a VPN which most primaries without domains wouldn't haveWay better over VPN/remote links due to a much faster network stack
Would you really mix a Win2000 sever and win7 clients - really? (and doesn't apply to non-domain use anyway )More managability via GP even if you only have a Windows 2000 server as DC
Non of these come close to being justification to spend loads of dosh on old machines
to restate - is there anything in Win7 ITSELF - i think not - the defence (or prosecution) rests their case millord
Did they ask for itOne of the primaries i cove is going to windows 7.
To plagairise - "But Mr Dent, the plans have been available in the local planning office for the last nine months."I am going to Windows Server 2008 R2 with Windows 7 Enterprise at easter. The staff know and have had access to a couple of test machines since September
but they will have to get used to it
:rotflol:and have had plenty of time to look at the software during ppa time etc.
 wheres the icon I need?[/edit]
Last edited by SimpleSi; 30th January 2010 at 05:00 PM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)